5.1 - Summary of Productivity Estimation
Enroll to start learning
You’ve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
Introduction to Production Estimation
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Today, we'll dive into productivity estimation for scrapers. Can anyone explain why productivity matters in construction?
It helps us understand how effectively we can complete tasks within budget.
Exactly! Productivity affects both timelines and costs. Let's break down how we estimate this using the number of scrapers.
How does the number of scrapers affect this?
Good question! If we have fewer scrapers than needed, they become critical to production, causing others like the pusher to wait. This example illustrates critical path dependency.
So, if scrapers are critical, does that slow down the whole process?
Yes! With five scrapers controlling production, let's calculate our output.
As a memory aid, remember 'SCRAP' for Scraper costs result in average productivity: S = Scrapers, C = Cycle times, R = Rates of output, A = Analysis, P = Production estimates.
To summarize, we control aggregate output based on the most limited resource. Today we learned about the implications of the number of scrapers.
Productivity Calculations
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Let’s calculate productivity. With five scrapers, we get a productivity rate of 636.89 bank cubic meters per hour. Who can find the formula?
I think it involves multiplying the number of scrapers by the volume per load and dividing by the cycle time?
Correct! For example, using 19.82 bank cubic meters per load and a cycle time of 7.78 minutes, we find how many hours it runs in an hour, considering job efficiency.
What about when we have six scrapers?
We're able to increase productivity to 723.36! This transition is vital in decision-making for project management.
Isn’t it all about balancing productivity with costs?
Absolutely! We'll calculate the cost next to determine efficiency and savings. Remember the acronym 'COST' for understanding Cost: C = Current process, O = Output metrics, S = Savings, T = Total cost.
In summary, calculating productivity is valuable but analyzing costs is equally essential to project success.
Cost Analysis
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now, let’s talk about cost analysis. What importance does this have in choosing scrapers?
It determines which combination gives the best value for money?
Exactly! For example, the cost with five scrapers is ₹44.12 per bank cubic meter, while six costs ₹45.07. What does that imply?
We should go for five scrapers since it's cheaper!
Correct! Ultimately, the decision should focus on both productivity and cost effectiveness. We must carefully evaluate our options based on these findings.
What would happen if we ignore cost?
We risk surpassing our budget! It's essential to balance output with expenses. Remember 'BUDGET': Balance = Understand decision, Budget equals Expectations, Goals, Utilize resources effectively, Total output.
To conclude today's lesson, we discern the rate of productivity versus cost efficacy shapes our operational strategy.
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
The section evaluates the productivity of scrapers based on their number and the cycle time required for different configurations. It explains how to calculate production rates for both fewer and more scrapers in relation to the critical nature of the pushers, ultimately leading to a cost-benefit analysis for optimized operational efficiency.
Detailed
Summary of Productivity Estimation
In this section, we analyze the economics of using scrapers in construction operations. Scrapers are key to effective material handling, but their productivity depends on how many are employed relative to the critical role of the pusher. When utilizing five scrapers, we highlight that the scrapers' limited availability will control production, causing pushers to wait. A detailed calculation reveals that with five scrapers and a cycle time of 7.78 minutes, the productivity equals 636.89 bank cubic meters per hour.
If six scrapers are used, the productivity increases to 723.36 bank cubic meters per hour. The analysis concludes that while more scrapers enhance productivity, they also raise production costs. By comparing unit production costs for both configurations, it's established that five scrapers at a cost of ₹44.12 per bank cubic meter is more economical than six at ₹45.07. The insights provided in this section are pivotal for making informed decisions in operational management, highlighting the importance of the balance between efficiency and cost.
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
Understanding the Impact of Scraper Numbers
Chapter 1 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Now let us consider the economics of going for 5 scrapers. So, 5 in the sense you are going to use lesser than what is needed, you are assuming 5 that means you are going to use the number of scrapers lesser than what is needed. So, when the number of scrapers are lesser than the balanced number so obviously scrapers are more critical, but a pusher will have the ideal time. Your pusher will wait for the scraper.
Detailed Explanation
This chunk explains the impact of having fewer scrapers than needed for a task. When there are fewer scrapers (in this example, 5), they are in higher demand, and their availability controls the workflow. The pusher, which supports the scrapers, is underutilized because it must wait for the scrapers to be free before it can do its job. Thus, it's crucial to find the right balance in the number of scrapers and pushers to optimize overall production.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a busy restaurant kitchen where there are only two chefs (scrapers) and four servers (pushers). If there are only two chefs, they will be overwhelmed with orders, making the servers wait. However, if there are more chefs, the servers can keep serving dishes without delays. This analogy shows that having the right number of chefs (scrapers) affects the restaurant's efficiency.
Calculating Scraper Production
Chapter 2 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, here the scraper will be controlling the production as a scraper is a lesser in number, but the pusher will have the ideal time. So, now, let us see the productivity this case of n equal to 5 scrapers. How to estimate the production of this scraper? The volume of your bowl volume per load, you know the value of 19.82 bank cubic meter. Production (Scraper controlling) Efficiency, hr = (volume per load × no. of scrapers) / (cycle time of scraper, min) * (job efficiency, min/hr) =... 636.89 bcm/hr.
Detailed Explanation
This chunk outlines how to calculate the production capability of the scrapers when using 5 units. The formula includes the volume of material the scraper can hold, the number of scrapers, and the time each takes to complete their cycle. The resulting figure indicates how much material can be moved per hour – here, 636.89 bank cubic meters per hour. This calculation ensures that the proper amount of production is recognized, which is essential for project planning.
Examples & Analogies
Consider a large conveyor belt that can move 19.82 cubic meters of garbage per load. If you have 5 trucks (scrapers) loading garbage, and each truck takes about 7.78 minutes to complete a load while working effectively for 50 minutes in an hour, you can estimate how much garbage can be moved in an hour using the formula provided.
Analyzing Increased Scraper Numbers
Chapter 3 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
If n is greater than the balance number that means you are going to use more number of scrapers, then what is indicated by the balance number. In this case, scrapers will have the ideal time. Scrapers are not critical. So, the scraper will be waiting for the pusher. Pusher is critical here.
Detailed Explanation
This chunk discusses the opposite scenario, where there are more scrapers than the balance number needed for operation. In this case, the scrapers may not be working at full capacity because they are waiting on the pusher to be available to continue operations. Here, the pusher determines the pace of production since scrapers have idle time waiting for their counterpart to transport the load.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a factory assembly line where each workstation is a separate task – for example, packing items, labeling, and stamping them. If there are too many workers at the labeling station but not enough at the packing station, the labeling workers will be idle while they wait for items to be packed. Therefore, the packing station (pusher) controls the speed of the entire line.
Calculating Costs and Choosing Efficiencies
Chapter 4 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Based on productivity if I select obviously I have to go for 6 number of scrapers per pusher, because 5 scrapers is giving you 636.89, 6 scrapers is giving you 723.36 bank cubic meters per hour. So, obviously 6 scrapers per pusher is giving you higher productivity.
Detailed Explanation
This chunk highlights the decision-making process regarding the number of scrapers selected based on their productivity. By analyzing the hourly production rates of both 5 and 6 scrapers, it becomes evident that 6 scrapers yield more material movement per hour (723.36 bank cubic meters), which would be the preferable choice if productivity is the primary concern.
Examples & Analogies
Think of a delivery team using bicycles. If one team has 5 bicycles and completes 636 deliveries in an hour, while another team with 6 bicycles can manage 723 deliveries, the more bicycles provide better productivity. Businesses often opt for more resources if it means getting more work done efficiently.
Estimating Production Costs
Chapter 5 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Let us now estimate the cost. How to calculate the unit production cost? Total unit cost of production for combination = [Cost of Pusher tractor with operator + Cost of scraper with operator × no. of scrapers] / Job production. So, it is nothing but you hourly cost by hourly productivity.
Detailed Explanation
This chunk explains how to estimate unit production costs by taking into account both operational and ownership costs and dividing that total by how much productivity is generated per hour. It emphasizes the importance of factoring in all costs associated with machinery when evaluating different productivity levels, which helps make good business decisions regarding equipment and labor use.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine you run a lemonade stand. You spend $20 on ingredients, cups, and a small stand setup, which allows you to sell 100 lemonades. To find out how much each cup costs you in production, you’d divide your total costs ($20) by your total output (100 cups), calculating a unit cost of $0.20 per lemonade.
Final Decision-Making in Production Estimates
Chapter 6 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, if you are concerned more about your production cost only in that case most of the cases people are concerned only about minimizing the production cost. So, in that case we have to go for the combination which gives you the minimum unit production cost.
Detailed Explanation
This final chunk focuses on the decision-making aspect where cost is prioritized over productivity against time pressures. The conclusion drawn from the earlier productivity calculations is that it’s often wiser in construction projects to select machinery configurations that minimize costs even if they don't maximize output.
Examples & Analogies
In managing a household, consider whether to buy a larger, more expensive washing machine that cleans clothes faster versus a smaller, cheaper model that takes longer. If your focus is strictly on saving money, you might choose the smaller model even if it requires more time to complete the task.
Key Concepts
-
Productivity Estimation: The assessment of how effectively resources are used in production processes.
-
Balancing Resources: The relationship between scrapers and pushers must optimize productivity and cost.
-
Operational Efficiency: Achieving high output while minimizing operational costs.
Examples & Applications
Using five scrapers yields a production rate of 636.89 bank cubic meters per hour.
Using six scrapers increases the yield to 723.36 bank cubic meters per hour but results in higher costs.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
When scrapers are few, production might slow; get just enough to make the workflow go.
Stories
Imagine Bob the Builder has one pusher and five scrapers, but they're slow because Bob didn't know five was just one too few. He adds one more and they work like a dream, moving materials—a perfect team!
Memory Tools
Use 'PEACE' for remembering factors affecting efficiency: P = Productivity rate, E = Equipment type, A = and number of scrapers, C = Cycle times, E = Efficiency of operations.
Acronyms
REMEMBER
Remember Estimation of Machines' Economics Based on Resources
output
and Efficiency.
Flash Cards
Glossary
- Scraper
A machine used for transporting bulk materials, typically earth or aggregate.
- Pusher
A machine that assists scrapers by pushing them from behind to improve efficiency.
- Cycle Time
The total time taken for a scraper to complete one full cycle of loading and hauling.
- Production Rate
The efficiency measure of output produced, calculated per hour.
- Unit Production Cost
Cost incurred to produce one unit of output, calculated based on total expenses in relation to the output achieved.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.