Designing Culturally Responsive Built Environments in Disaster Context
Enroll to start learning
You’ve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
Importance of Cultural Understanding
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
To successfully design built environments in disaster contexts, we must understand the cultural issues at play. Can anyone explain why culture is crucial here?
I think culture influences how people live and what they value in their communities.
Exactly! If we ignore cultural elements, the built environments may not satisfy community needs.
Great points! We use the acronym CRAFT - Culture, Recovery, Adaptation, Facilities, and Time. Each element plays a vital role in the design process.
So, CRAFT emphasizes that cultural understanding should occupy a central place in our design strategies.
Exactly. Let's summarize: understanding culture shapes our recovery efforts and the built environments we create.
Case Study: Cappadocia, Turkey
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now, let's examine Cappadocia, Turkey. Why do people return despite knowing the risks of earthquakes?
Because it’s a tourist spot! The economy provides a strong pull for residents.
Also, their cultural attachment to the place makes them want to live there, regardless of the dangers.
Excellent insights! This case highlights how economic and cultural factors intertwine in disaster recovery. Remember, safety and livelihood often coexist in people's decision-making.
So, culture not only influences where people live but also how they perceive risks, right?
Precisely! Safety and livelihood balance is crucial to understanding community resilience.
Learning from Gibellina, Italy
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Let's discuss the reconstruction efforts in Gibellina, Italy. What went wrong in their approach?
They focused too much on modernity and not enough on the actual people's needs.
And the empty plazas show how the designs didn’t facilitate social interactions.
Exactly! The lack of community engagement and mismanagement led to an unfinished urban landscape. This demonstrates the need for participatory design.
So, the lesson here is ensuring that the community is involved in the planning process?
Precisely! Local participation leads to spaces that better reflect community needs.
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
The section discusses how cultural considerations impact disaster recovery and how environments must adapt to meet the diverse needs of communities in pre, during, and post-disaster contexts. It highlights case studies from Turkey and Italy, showcasing both effective and ineffective recovery strategies.
Detailed
Designing Culturally Responsive Built Environments in Disaster Context
This section delves into the importance of incorporating cultural responsiveness in the design of built environments, particularly during disaster recovery. The discussion begins by stressing that understanding cultural issues is vital to meet community needs, which evolve from the pre-disaster phase to the aftermath of a disaster.
Key contributions from researcher Paul Oliver highlight how cultural aspects have often been disregarded in recovery efforts, leading to spaces that fail to resonate with the impacted communities. The section underscores the complex relationship between development and culture by examining various case studies.
Using Turkey's Cappadocia region and the 1968 earthquake in Gibellina, Italy, as primary examples, it illustrates how environmental designs can either facilitate or hinder community resilience. The case of Cappadocia shows how communities, despite knowing the risks, return due to economic opportunities such as tourism, while the Gibellina reconstruction experience reveals the pitfalls of overlooking local cultural needs and the potential for wasted resources in the name of modernism.
In conclusion, the section calls for a nuanced understanding of cultural significance in disaster recovery, advocating for plans that acknowledge community identity and promotes social cohesion.
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
Understanding Cultural Response in Disaster Context
Chapter 1 of 5
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
When we talk about the culturally responsive built environments in a disaster context, one has to understand the basics of the cultural issues and how especially, they are related to the built to meet needs and how they change from the pre-disaster context during disaster and the post-disaster context and over a long-run process.
Detailed Explanation
This chunk highlights the importance of understanding cultural issues when designing environments in disaster contexts. It emphasizes that a thorough comprehension of how cultural needs evolve through different phases — pre-disaster, disaster, and post-disaster — is crucial. We must address not just physical rebuilding, but also the cultural significance of the spaces where communities live.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a community that loses its main market area due to a flood. While rebuilding the structures is essential, the designers must also consider what the market meant to the people: a gathering place, a source of income, and a hub of culture. Simply rebuilding buildings without considering these cultural aspects may lead to a lifeless space rather than a thriving community venue.
Contribution of Paul Oliver's Work
Chapter 2 of 5
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
This is where, I would like to introduce you to the contribution of Paul Oliver's work on built to meet needs on especially the part IV on cultures, disasters and dwellings and he brings a number of cases along with it and how culture has been overlooked in the recovery process and as a result what kind of spaces are produced and as a response situation what kind of meanings have developed.
Detailed Explanation
In this section, the importance of Paul Oliver's contributions is underscored, particularly regarding how cultural needs have been overlooked in disaster recovery processes. His work showcases various cases demonstrating the kinds of spaces created when culture is neglected, and how these spaces can carry meanings for the affected communities.
Examples & Analogies
Think of a town affected by a hurricane that replaces its community center, a beloved traditional gathering space, with a generic shelter. While the new space technically serves a purpose, it lacks the cultural significance and connection that the original center provided, resulting in a community that feels disjointed from its roots and unable to rebuild its identity.
Case Study: Cavusin Village, Turkey
Chapter 3 of 5
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
In fact, there are some of the case studies in Cavusin village in the old Greek town which is about 4 kilometres from the Goreme-Avanos road. So, here it’s a kind of big mountain which is embedded with a lot of dwellings which are intricate dwellings which are embedded like a mountain, what you can see is that all the dwellings, series of dwellings which are very organic nature of it.
Detailed Explanation
This chunk introduces a specific case study from Cavusin village in Turkey, which is notable for its organically integrated dwellings within the mountainous landscape. These homes have been affected by frequent earthquakes and environmental erosion, illustrating the challenges of maintaining cultural heritage amid physical vulnerabilities.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a village built into the side of a hill, where homes are shaped by the land. When an earthquake shakes the village, it can lead to crumbling homes that hold the community's history and identity. It’s like losing pieces of a puzzle that represent the community's unique story and connections, which can be harder to recover than just repairing the buildings.
Economic Factors in Resettlement Decisions
Chapter 4 of 5
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Many of the communities they denied going back. They came back and they try to settle in the vicinity of this village, despite of knowing that this place is prone to earthquakes and there is a danger, they are going to live on this edge conditions but still, why do you think that these people have come and stayed here back.
Detailed Explanation
Here, it is discussed why some community members choose to return to a disaster-prone area despite the risks. The decision to return often involves not only safety concerns but also economic factors, such as the opportunities presented by tourism and traditional livelihoods that tie them to the land.
Examples & Analogies
Consider a fisherman who lives in a coastal town that is vulnerable to storms. Despite the risks, he chooses to stay because fishing is his family legacy, and the town attracts tourists who support the local economy. This decision illustrates how deeply intertwined livelihood and culture can influence choices in the face of disaster.
The Role of Eradication After Disaster
Chapter 5 of 5
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
In 1968, there has been a vast earthquake which has destroyed the restaurant Sicily almost leaving 1 lakh people homeless. There is a small city called Gibellina which was completely razed to the ground and its community of shepherds and farm labourers relocated to the temporary tent camps.
Detailed Explanation
This chunk recounts the catastrophic earthquake in Sicily, which led to significant devastation. It highlights how disaster can uproot entire communities, forcing them into temporary shelters, and sets the stage for discussing community rebuilding as an opportunity rather than a setback.
Examples & Analogies
Think of a wildfire that completely burns a town. The immediate aftermath involves chaos, loss, and despair, but it can also present a chance for the community to envision what a rebuilt town may look like — perhaps even more beautiful and resilient than before. This can lead to collaborative efforts and new ideas in urban planning.
Key Concepts
-
Cultural Responsiveness: The need for design to reflect community identities.
-
Case Studies: Importance of learning from both successes and failures in disaster recovery.
-
Participatory Design: Engaging communities in the design process enhances relevance and usability.
-
Resilience: Communities’ ability to adapt to and recover from disasters is crucial to effective rebuilding.
Examples & Applications
Cappadocia, Turkey exemplifies how tourists can attract residents back to risk-prone areas due to economic opportunities.
Gibellina, Italy serves as a cautionary tale where modernistic designs failed to meet the community's needs, leading to social isolation.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
Culture is key, so let it flow; in disaster, it helps us grow.
Stories
Imagine a town hit by disaster. The leaders forgot the people's culture in rebuilding. The plazas stood empty, but in a neighboring town, the memories of the past brought people back, showing the power of culture.
Memory Tools
Remember the acronym CRAFT: Culture, Recovery, Adaptation, Facilities, Time - the components of effective disaster response.
Acronyms
Use SPECTRUM - Safety, Participation, Economic, Cultural, Time, Resources, Understanding, Meaning - to remember important factors in disaster recovery.
Flash Cards
Glossary
- Culturally Responsive Design
An approach to design that acknowledges and respects cultural differences and seeks to meet the diverse needs of communities.
- Disaster Recovery
The process of rebuilding and restoring infrastructure and communities after a disaster.
- Participatory Design
A design process that involves all stakeholders, especially the end users, in the design development.
- Resilience
The ability of individuals or communities to adapt and recover from adverse events effectively.
- Economic Pull
Factors that draw individuals back to a location due to job opportunities or commercial prospects.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.