11 - APPROXIMATE FRAME ANALYSIS
Enroll to start learning
You’ve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
Introduction to Approximate Analysis
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Hello everyone! Today, we're going to explore approximate frame analysis. Why do you think we would use approximate methods despite modern computational tools?
Maybe because some structures behave differently than we expect?
Great point! We recognize the ability of structures to redistribute forces. This leads to our first key assumption: the validity of linear elastic analysis. Can someone explain why this might be important?
It might help us figure out how to design without calculating everything precisely.
Exactly! This approach simplifies our calculations while still providing reliable results. Remember the acronym 'RED' for Redistribution, Elasticity, and Design to help keep these concepts in mind!
Vertical and Horizontal Loads
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now let’s talk about how we treat vertical and horizontal loads. Why do you think these loads are considered separately?
Because they can affect the structure in different ways!
That's right! Vertical loads and horizontal loads can lead to different stability issues. Always remember to sketch the free body diagrams with positive forces and moments. Who can give me the design sign convention for moments?
Moments are positive when counterclockwise and negative when clockwise, right?
Excellent! And for shear forces? We also have a convention for those.
I think it's the same - counterclockwise is positive, right?
Exactly! Remember this simple rule for your calculations.
Inflection Points and Deformed Shape
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Let’s discuss how we identify inflection points in structures. Why are these points crucial?
They show where the bending moment shifts, right?
Exactly! By understanding where these inflection points are, we can better understand the internal forces. How do we sketch the deformed shape of a structure?
By considering how the structure will really deflect under load?
Yes! This helps us visualize and assess how the structure will behave under actual conditions. Remember, sketching helps in both analysis and understanding!
Multi-Bay and Multi-Storey Frames
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now, let’s scale up to multi-bay and multi-storey frames. What assumptions do we consider when analyzing these frames?
The girders are continuous and columns resist unbalanced moments?
Exactly! Understanding these assumptions is important for accurate analysis. How do we determine reactions for these more complex structures?
We use static equilibrium equations, right?
Correct! Always ensure to apply the sum of forces and moments equations to find accurate results.
Application Scenarios
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Finally, let’s think about how we would apply all of these concepts in a real-world scenario. Can anyone suggest an example?
Maybe designing a bridge or a tall building?
Yes, both are excellent examples! Different loads and deflection considerations will apply. How do we ensure our designs are safe under these methodologies?
By ensuring we account for all loads and using equivalent static methods!
Absolutely! It's important to flexibly adapt our analysis methods based on the project requirements. Remember to always refer to the 'RED' concepts for simplifying complex scenarios. Great job today, everyone!
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
This section outlines the justification for using approximate methods in structural analysis, detailing key assumptions regarding force redistribution, load uncertainties, and the treatment of vertical and horizontal loads separately. It highlights the importance of defect shapes and inflection points in beam and frame analysis.
Detailed
Approximating Frame Analysis
The Approximate Frame Analysis section delves into the rationale for utilizing approximate methods in structural analysis despite the availability of advanced computing resources. The justification is based on several key assumptions:
1. Validity of Linear Elastic Analysis: It hinges on the acceptance of linear elastic analysis for ultimate failure designs.
2. Force Redistribution: Structures can redistribute internal forces, allowing for simplifications in analysis.
3. Load and Material Uncertainties: The recognition that uncertainties in loads and material properties necessitate an approximate approach.
Vertical and horizontal loads are treated distinctly, and a systematic approach is outlined:
- A design convention is established for moments and shear forces.
- Girders are numbered systematically from left to right.
- Positive forces and moments are the norm in free-body diagrams.
- Critical to the analysis is the ability to sketch a structure's deformed shape and identify inflection points.
The section emphasizes that for uniform loads, the method allows for accurate determination of reactions and internal forces while treating continuous beams and columns in multi-storey frames appropriately.
Youtube Videos
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
Justification for Approximate Analysis
Chapter 1 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Despite the widespread availability of computers, approximate methods of analysis are justified by:
1. Inherent assumption made regarding the validity of a linear elastic analysis vis-a-vis of an ultimate failure design.
2. Ability of structures to redistribute internal forces.
3. Uncertainties in load and material properties.
Detailed Explanation
Approximate methods of analysis may seem outdated given the current technology that allows for precise calculations. However, they are still relevant for several crucial reasons. First, linear elastic analysis often assumes ideal conditions that may not hold in real-world scenarios, hence approximations are necessary. Second, structures can often redistribute forces internally, allowing us to understand potential failure modes better. Third, actual properties of materials and loads may vary due to uncertainties, and approximate methods help account for these variations.
Examples & Analogies
Think of building a bridge using only the most precise models without considering real-world variables like temperature change affecting materials. An approximation could help address these uncertainties, much like how a chef adjusts the seasoning by taste rather than strictly following a recipe.
Load Consideration
Chapter 2 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Vertical loads are treated separately from the horizontal ones.
Detailed Explanation
In structural analysis, it's critical to treat vertical and horizontal loads separately since they affect the structure in different ways. Vertical loads (like weight from buildings) primarily cause compression or tension, while horizontal loads (like wind) can induce shear forces and moments that can lead to bending. Understanding the distinctions allows engineers to better predict how a structure will respond under various load conditions.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine holding a book vertically versus pushing it sideways. When you only think of gravity (vertical), you would stack books to hold it upright. When pushing from the side (horizontal), you would need to ensure it’s supported from both directions to prevent it from toppling.
Design Sign Convention
Chapter 3 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
We use the design sign convention for moments (+ve tension below), and for shear (ccw +ve).
Detailed Explanation
The design sign convention is essential for consistency in structural analysis. In this context, a positive moment generally indicates that the element is bending in a way that reduces tension, for example, tension is below the neutral axis of a beam in bending. Similarly, convention for shear forces helps ensure that all calculations are in line with the expected behavior of the structure under loads. This systematic approach prevents errors in assessing the performance of structural members.
Examples & Analogies
It's akin to proper navigation in a car. Having a uniform convention for what 'left' and 'right' mean helps prevent confusion when following directions, just as the design convention clarifies how forces and moments behave in a structure.
Identifying Deflected Shapes
Chapter 4 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
The key to the approximate analysis method is our ability to sketch the deflected shape of a structure and identify inflection points.
Detailed Explanation
In analyzing structures, understanding how they deflect under loads is critical for determining whether they will fail. Sketching the deflected shape helps visualize where stress concentrations might occur. Inflection points, where curvature changes, are especially important since they indicate where the bending moment is zero, which can greatly influence structural performance.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine bending a piece of paper. The more you bend it, the more it curves until a point where it seems to not bend more (inflection point). Recognizing this not only helps prevent tearing but allows you to adjust your forces before failure occurs.
Extreme Cases of Restraint
Chapter 5 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
In each case, we consider an extreme end of the restraint: a) free or b) restrained. For the frame, a relatively flexible or stiff column would be analogous to a free or fixed restraint on the beam.
Detailed Explanation
Understanding the types of support or restraint on beams and frames is fundamental in structural analysis. A 'free' end allows for rotation, often leading to less internal stress, whereas a 'restrained' end limits movement and can significantly increase stress within the structure. The behavior of columns impacts how beams interact with loads and support, necessitating a careful assessment based on the anticipated column flexural rigidity.
Examples & Analogies
Think of a swing that is either supported freely on a chain (free) or one that is wedged tightly against a pole (restrained). The swing’s movement and stresses would differ significantly based on this support, similar to how a beam performs under different end conditions.
Static Equilibrium for Forces
Chapter 6 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
With the location of the inflection points identified, we may now determine all the reactions and internal forces from statics.
Detailed Explanation
Once inflection points are established, engineers can apply static equilibrium principles to analyze reactions and forces within a structure. This involves summing the forces and moments acting on the structure to ensure that, under equilibrium, the net effect is zero. It's essential for understanding how the application of loads translates into internal stresses and potential failure points.
Examples & Analogies
Consider balancing a seesaw. To keep it level, the weight on both sides must be equal. This same principle applies when determining forces in a structure—knowing that everything must balance helps predict how the whole system functions together.
Key Concepts
-
Approximation Methods: Techniques used to simplify structural analyses.
-
Force Redistribution: Structures can adjust internal forces to remain stable.
-
Inflection Points: Important for assessing bending moments in beams.
-
Static Equilibrium: The foundational principle that balances forces.
Examples & Applications
A design of a bridge that requires considering both vertical loads from traffic and horizontal loads from wind pressure.
Calculating the internal forces and reactions of a multi-storey frame under varying load conditions.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
For loads both heavy and light, verticals drop, horizontals fight!
Stories
Imagine a bridge challenging the forces of nature, with each beam redistributing the loads like a wise sage flexing its muscles, preventing collapse.
Memory Tools
Remember 'RED': Redistribution, Elasticity, and Design to summarize the core aspects of approximate frame analysis.
Acronyms
USE
Understand
Simplify
Execute - the steps for approximate analysis.
Flash Cards
Glossary
- Approximate Frame Analysis
A method used to analyze structures by simplifying certain aspects while accepting some inaccuracies.
- Inflection Points
Locations in the beam or structural element where the curvature changes sign, indicating a change in bending moment.
- Vertical Loads
Forces acting downwards on a structure, typically from the weight of the structure and additional loads.
- Horizontal Loads
Forces acting horizontally on a structure, such as wind or seismic activity.
- Design Sign Convention
A specific agreement on the direction of forces and moments deemed positive or negative in structural analysis.
- Static Equilibrium
A condition wherein all forces and moments acting on a structure sum to zero, resulting in no motion.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.