4.2.2 - When Trucks are Greater Than the Balanced Number
Enroll to start learning
You’ve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
Understanding Balanced Numbers
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Today, we are discussing the balanced number of trucks in relation to excavators. This is crucial because it influences our productivity. Can anyone tell me what the balanced number means?
Is it the ideal number of trucks we should have for one excavator?
Exactly! The balanced number allows for optimal machine operation with minimal idle time. If we have too many trucks, we face inefficiencies.
What happens if we overload the trucks beyond this number?
Good question! When we have more trucks than the balanced number, we risk having trucks waiting and increasing costs while decreasing overall productivity.
So, is there a certain ratio we should stick to?
Yes! The general rule is that the truck capacity should be 4 to 5 times the bucket capacity of the excavator. This balance helps maintain efficiency. Remember: Balance equals productivity!
What’s a good way to remember that?
You can use the acronym B.E.E. - 'Balanced Machines Ensure Efficiency.' Understanding this relationship is key!
Calculating Productivity
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now let’s talk about calculating productivity based on load factors. Can someone remind me how to approach this?
We multiply the truck load by the number of trucks and divide by the truck cycle time?
That's correct! If we adjust the truck load based on the bucket capacity and fill factor, we can understand the realistic output.
So if my truck can take 10.3 cubic meters, how do I factor in the fill rate?
Great point! You'll adjust the capacity based on the fill factor. For instance, if your fill factor is 0.9, then your effective capacity is 10.3 times 0.9.
What if I end up with a short load? Does that impact my calculations?
Absolutely! Short loads can lead to underutilization. Always aim to ensure that the loads are close to the rated capacity for efficiency.
Consequences of Overloading
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Let's dive into the consequences of overloading trucks. Can anyone share what might happen in such scenarios?
More wear and tear on the machinery, right?
Absolutely! Overloading leads to increased wear on tires and other components, driving up maintenance costs.
Is there a rule of thumb for maintenance costs?
Yes, tires can constitute up to 35% of a truck's operating cost. Avoiding overload can significantly impact your bottom line!
What about the overall project cost?
Great point! Premature aging of trucks leads to higher replacement costs, and productivity losses would weigh heavily on your annual budget.
Making Economical Decisions
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now that we understand the consequences, how do we make economic decisions about the number of trucks?
We should analyze costs at both rounded truck numbers, right?
Perfect! Compare the costs for 7 and 8 trucks and evaluate production outputs to see which is more viable.
Shouldn’t we also consider equipment break downtimes?
Absolutely! Minimizing continuous operation of the loader can help avoid significant disruptions.
So, it's about finding that balance of efficiency and reliability?
Exactly! Balancing economics, operation time, and efficiency is critical for successful project management. Remember, a well-planned strategy saves costs!
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
The section explains how exceeding the balanced number of trucks relative to excavators can lead to idle time for trucks and inefficiencies in productivity. It emphasizes the importance of understanding machine capacities and the relationship between truck cycle times and excavators.
Detailed
When Trucks are Greater Than the Balanced Number
In construction operations, efficient coordination between trucks and excavators is critical for optimizing productivity. This section elucidates how using more trucks than the balanced number can lead to various operational challenges.
Key Points Covered
- Balanced Number of Trucks: The balanced number refers to the optimal number of trucks that allow for maximum utilization of an excavator, where the cycle times of both equipment harmonize.
- Effects of Overloading Trucks: When the number of trucks exceeds the balanced number, the excavator may not be able to keep up with the truck's demands. This can lead to idle trucks, resulting in wasted time and reduced overall efficiency.
- Production Calculation: The productivity can be calculated based on truck loads and cycle times, with each scenario presenting different outcomes depending on whether trucks are below or above the balanced number. It's crucial to ensure that any increase in truck numbers is economically justifiable, factoring in both operational costs and potential productivity losses.
- Economic Considerations: The text discusses the importance of maintaining a pragmatic approach to loading and balancing machinery. Overloading can harm equipment and result in increased costs over time.
- Operational Strategies: Understanding the intricacies of loader performance, truck payload capacities, and efficient cycle times can help in effectively managing large construction projects.
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
Understanding Gravimetric Capacity
Chapter 1 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
But the loading time will be number of bucket loads multiplied by the bucket cycle time. ... So, only that capacity your machine can take because the structural frame of the machine is designed to handle that particular load only.
Detailed Explanation
In construction and heavy machinery operation, understanding gravimetric capacity is crucial. This capacity refers to the maximum weight that a machine can safely handle, as provided by the manufacturer. It's fundamental to adhere to this limit to avoid damaging the machine. Overloading can lead to structural issues, excessive wear, and reduce the machine's lifespan. Therefore, consistently checking the load weight against the gravimetric capacity is essential.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a weightlifter who can only safely lift a certain amount of weight without risking injury. If they try to lift beyond their capacity, it can lead to serious injury. Similarly, heavy machinery has limits, and exceeding these can cause costly damage.
The Risks of Overloading Trucks
Chapter 2 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, since the density of material can vary from case to case, it is always advisable to check whether the load weight is within the safe gravimetric capacity. ... if you keep on overloading your truck it will result in premature aging of the truck.
Detailed Explanation
When trucks are overloaded, especially with denser materials such as wet sand, the risk of damage increases significantly. This can lead to higher operational costs due to more frequent tire replacements and repairs. It's essential to regularly verify the weight of the load to ensure it doesn't exceed the truck's rated gravimetric capacity to avoid these issues.
Examples & Analogies
Consider a car overloaded with passengers and luggage. If the car is pushed beyond its designed carrying capacity, it could face tire blowouts or even engine problems, which illustrates the importance of adhering to weight limits.
The Importance of Balance in Hauling Operations
Chapter 3 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Now let us see how to balance the interdependent machines, trucks and the excavators. ... So, balancing the capacity of the hauling equipment and the excavator bucket size will result in maximum loading efficiency, and reduce total cost.
Detailed Explanation
Balancing the number of trucks and excavators is essential in construction operations to maximize productivity. Ideally, the truck capacity should be 4 to 5 times the capacity of the excavator bucket. This balance ensures that the loading and hauling operations are synchronized, reducing downtime and optimizing work processes.
Examples & Analogies
Think of a relay race where each runner must pass a baton to the next at just the right moment. If one runner is too fast or too slow, it causes delays and inefficiencies. Similarly, in construction, ensuring that trucks and excavators are balanced is crucial for smooth operations.
Calculating the Balanced Number of Trucks
Chapter 4 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, that depends upon the cycle time of your truck and the cycle time of your excavator. So, divide the truck cycle time by the excavator cycle time, you will get the balance number of trucks.
Detailed Explanation
The balanced number of trucks is determined by comparing the cycle times of the trucks and excavators. This involves calculating the cycle time of the truck (which includes loading, hauling, and dumping) and dividing it by the cycle time of the excavator. This calculation helps in determining how many trucks are adequately required to maintain efficient operations without causing delays.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a bus schedule where buses need to arrive at regular intervals. If one bus takes longer to complete its route, it affects the timing of the next bus. By understanding and calculating these times, we ensure that the buses (or in this case, trucks) arrive and depart efficiently.
Implications of Having More Trucks
Chapter 5 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, the number of trucks are greater than the balance number, so the trucks will have the idle time, truck will be waiting for the loader, loader will be critical here.
Detailed Explanation
When the number of trucks exceeds the balanced number, the trucks will sit idle, waiting for the loader to become available. This situation can lead to wastage of resources as trucks are not being utilized effectively. In scenarios where trucks are in excess, the loader's cycle time becomes the limiting factor for productivity, making it essential to find the right balance.
Examples & Analogies
Think of a classroom filled with too many students for the number of teachers available. If there are more students than teachers, many students may not receive the immediate attention they need, leading to inefficiencies in learning.
Economics of Rounding Truck Numbers
Chapter 6 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
But very commonly you can see that people prefer to round it to lower than balanced number... That is why people always prefer rounding it to lower number, but the logical way is to work out the economics of both the cases and then take a decision.
Detailed Explanation
In practice, many operators opt to round down the number of required trucks below the calculated balance number to reduce the risk of over-utilizing machinery, especially loaders. This precaution helps in maintaining equipment faster and prolongs its operational life. However, the decision should be economically driven by analyzing costs associated with both options.
Examples & Analogies
When planning a party, one might round down the number of guests to avoid overcrowding. While having fewer people might be safer and more manageable, budgeting for the food and drinks should also consider whether it meets the expected attendance to avoid waste.
Key Concepts
-
Balanced Number: The ideal number of trucks to ensure maximum productivity with an excavator.
-
Gravimetric Capacity: The safe maximum weight a machine can carry as determined by the manufacturer.
-
Cycle Time Importance: Each cycle time significantly impacts the efficiency and productivity of machinery.
-
Economic Impact of Overloading: Overloading machinery leads to increased costs and potential project delays.
Examples & Applications
If a truck's maximum capacity is 10.3m³ and the effective capacity considering the fill factor is 9.27m³, we must ensure that all loads are optimized to prevent inefficiencies.
When loading wet sand, which has a high density, it is essential to ensure the load does not surpass the gravimetric capacity of the truck.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
When loading high, don’t overload, keep it right, lighten your load.
Stories
Imagine a construction site where trucks race to fill up, but one truck always waits at the line. Learn to maintain that delicate balance so every truck rolls smoothly without idling.
Memory Tools
Remember B.E.E. - Balanced machines ensure efficiency in operations!
Acronyms
T.U.L.E. - Trucks should Utilize Load Efficiency to prevent overloading.
Flash Cards
Glossary
- Balanced Number
The optimal number of trucks to operate alongside an excavator for maximum efficiency.
- Gravimetric Capacity
The maximum load weight a machine can handle safely as rated by the manufacturer.
- Cycle Time
The total time required for a truck or excavator to complete a full operational cycle, including loading, hauling, and returning.
- Fill Factor
The efficiency of how well a truck or excavator can utilize its capacity during loading.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.