28.2.5 - Example of Bellman-Ford Algorithm
Enroll to start learning
You’ve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
Introduction to Shortest Paths and Negative Weights
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Today, we're discussing shortest paths in graphs, particularly when dealing with negative edge weights. Can anyone tell me why Dijkstra's algorithm fails under these conditions?
It's because it doesn't account for paths that might become shorter after visiting other vertices.
Exactly! The presence of negative edges allows a shorter path to potentially emerge later. We need a method that can manage these conditions - that's where the Bellman-Ford Algorithm comes into play.
What are some properties that we need to remember about shortest paths?
Great question! Two key properties are: firstly, the shortest path never contains loops, and secondly, every prefix of a shortest path is itself a shortest path. Remember this with the acronym 'NLP': No Loops, Prefix Validity.
Why can't we have negative cycles?
Negative cycles would cause a path length to decrease infinitely. This destabilizes our calculations, which is why we must avoid them.
To summarize: shortest paths cannot have loops, and every prefix needs to be valid. Remembering NLP will help.
Transitioning from Dijkstra's Algorithm to Bellman-Ford
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now let's look at how the Bellman-Ford Algorithm improves upon Dijkstra's approach. Who can remind us how Dijkstra's handles updates?
It updates the distances when a vertex is visited, and chooses the vertex with the smallest distance each time.
Correct! But this is problematic with negative weights because the expected shortest distance upon visiting might not actually be correct. The Bellman-Ford Algorithm addresses this by revisiting all edges multiple times.
How many times do we need to update the edges?
We perform this relaxation `V-1` times, where `V` is the number of vertices. This ensures that all paths have been evaluated for minimal lengths.
In essence, the Bellman-Ford Algorithm provides a comprehensive path evaluation, unlike Dijkstra's method. Remember, V-1 is crucial!
Implementing the Bellman-Ford Algorithm
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Let's now dive into how we actually implement the Bellman-Ford Algorithm. Can any student tell me the first step?
We need to initialize the distances from the source to infinity, except for the source itself which should be zero.
Correct! After initializing, we will begin the relaxation process. Who can explain what that involves?
We systematically check all the edges and update the distances if we find a shorter path.
Great! And we repeat this process how many times?
We go through this `V-1` times to ensure all paths are covered!
Excellent work! Finally, what can we do after these iterations for additional verification?
We can check one more time for negative cycles by looking for any further updates.
Exactly! Great job summarizing the Bellman-Ford Algorithm steps. Remember the process: initialize, relax, and verify.
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
The Bellman-Ford Algorithm allows the calculation of shortest paths in graphs accommodating negative edge weights while maintaining the integrity of distance computations. This section establishes fundamental properties of shortest paths before demonstrating the algorithm's step-by-step operation, highlighting its advantages over Dijkstra's algorithm in specific scenarios.
Detailed
Detailed Summary of the Bellman-Ford Algorithm
The Bellman-Ford Algorithm is a powerful method used to find the shortest paths from a single source vertex to all other vertices in a graph, even when negative edge weights are present. However, it is important to note that the algorithm does not work with graphs that contain negative cycles, as these cycles can lead to infinitely decreasing path lengths.
Key Properties of Shortest Paths
- No Loops: The shortest path between any two vertices will not contain loops. A loop can be eliminated from any path, and the remaining path will either equal or be shorter than the original.
- Path Validity: Every prefix of a shortest path is itself a shortest path. Thus, if there is a shorter route to an intermediate vertex in the path, the entire path can be further optimized.
Transition from Dijkstra's to Bellman-Ford
While Dijkstra's algorithm effectively calculates shortest paths assuming no negative weights, it fails in graphs with negative edges. The Bellman-Ford Algorithm overcomes this challenge by iterating through all edges multiple times: specifically, it performs a total of V-1 iterations on a graph with V vertices. In each iteration, it scans all the edges, updating the path lengths based on the current distances.
Algorithm Steps
- Initialize distances from the source to all vertices as infinity, with the distance to the source itself as 0.
- For each edge in the graph, apply relaxation to update the shortest path estimates.
- Repeat the relaxation step
V-1times. - Optionally perform one more iteration to check for negative weight cycles.
The Bellman-Ford Algorithm's methodology ensures that all possible paths are evaluated, capturing the minimal path lengths effectively.
Youtube Videos
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
Introduction to Shortest Paths with Negative Edge Weights
Chapter 1 of 4
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Now, let us look at shortest paths in graphs where we allow Negative Edge weights. In particular, let us look at the Bellman-Ford Algorithm.
However, as we saw this argument does not work if we can have negative edge weights, because we may find later a path via vertex which we have not burnt yet, which becomes a shorter path to a vertex we have burnt earlier.
Detailed Explanation
This chunk introduces the Bellman-Ford algorithm, which is designed to handle graphs that include edges with negative weights. Unlike Dijkstra's algorithm, which relies on a property of vertex 'burning' to guarantee shortest paths, the Bellman-Ford algorithm can deal with scenarios where negative edges alter the previously established shortest paths. This means that while a path to a given vertex may be computed, it’s possible later to find a new shorter path as we explore the graph further.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine you are planning a road trip and calculating the shortest route based on the current map. Halfway through the journey, you learn about a route that wasn't shown on the map, which is shorter due to a construction detour. This represents how additional exploration can lead to discovering shorter paths in a graph.
Properties of Shortest Paths
Chapter 2 of 4
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, let us first look at two basic properties about shortest paths which hold regardless of whether the edges can be negative or not, provided we do not have negative cycles. The first property is fairly obvious: a shortest path will never go through a loop.
Detailed Explanation
Two key properties govern the behavior of shortest paths in graphs: 1. A shortest path cannot contain loops; if it did, removing the loop would yield a direct and thus shorter path. 2. Every segment (or prefix) of a shortest path must also be the shortest path to that vertex. This means that if you can reach a vertex through a series of edges, any sub-path used to reach that vertex must also be optimal.
Examples & Analogies
Think about navigating through a maze. If you take a roundabout way that leads you back to a point you’ve already been, you can always cut back to the last point without that roundabout path, which is more efficient. This reflects the idea that loops only make the path longer.
Structure of the Bellman-Ford Algorithm
Chapter 3 of 4
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Bellman-Ford algorithm basically says do not write to your find the particular sequence, just generally compute all possible sequence have updates. So, at a high level this the algorithm: it says initially assign the distance of s to be 0 and the distance of u to be infinity for every other vertex.
Detailed Explanation
The Bellman-Ford algorithm initializes the process by setting the starting vertex's distance to zero and all other vertices to an infinite distance. It then performs updates across all edges in the graph for a maximum of n-1 passes. Each pass allows the algorithm to adjust the distances considering all possible paths that exist through the edges, with the assurance that, by n-1 updates, all shortest paths will be correctly reflected in the distance values.
Examples & Analogies
Consider a post office distributing mail. The initial route is plotted starting from the post office (the source vertex) to all address points (other vertices). Initially, the post office knows no deliveries can be made (infinity) except to itself (zero distance). With each round of deliveries (iterations), routes get updated based on neighbor addresses until all reachable addresses have the right postage (shortest path distances).
Example Demonstration
Chapter 4 of 4
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, let us look at an example and see how the Bellman Ford algorithm actually works. Here is a graph it has some cycles and it has some negative weights, but there are no negative cycles... Now, we will in the first step try to update all neighbors of things that we hear, now all values which are infinity do not update the neighbors, but the value 1 will it has 2 neighbors 2 only.
Detailed Explanation
In this example, we observe the workings of the Bellman-Ford algorithm as it processes a graph with edges having negative weights but no negative cycles. Iteratively, the algorithm updates distances by evaluating neighboring vertices and adjusting their distances based on the discovered shorter paths through them. This continuous updating continues for n-1 iterations to ensure all possible shortest paths are found.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a delivery route over several days. Each day, the delivery driver discovers new shortcuts or obstruction updates (negative edges). After each delivery (iteration), the driver reassesses the best path to ensure efficiency. Ultimately, by the end of the week (n-1 iterations), all destinations have the best route mapped out based on the discoveries made along the way.
Key Concepts
-
No Loops: The shortest path will never form a loop.
-
Prefix Validity: Every prefix of a shortest path is itself a shortest path.
-
Relaxation: Updating the shortest path estimates based on new information.
-
Iterations: Bellman-Ford requires V-1 iterations for a graph with V vertices.
Examples & Applications
In a graph where vertex A connects to vertex B with a weight of -2, Dijkstra's algorithm may incorrectly assume the distance is higher due to negative weight, which Bellman-Ford can correctly account for.
In a graph with vertices connected in a cycle that has a total weight of -5, the Bellman-Ford algorithm will recognize that continuously traversing the cycle can yield decreasing path values.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
In paths that twist and plots that bend, watch for negatives, they are your end!
Stories
Once in a land of Weighted Graphs, a brave knight named Pathfinder sought to find the best routes for journeys. He realized some paths were shorter by revisiting vertices, but had to ensure he wasn't trapped in negative loops.
Memory Tools
NLP - No Loops, Valid Prefixes; remind yourself every time you evaluate paths.
Acronyms
V-1
Remember the number of iterations needed - the graph vertices minus one!
Flash Cards
Glossary
- Shortest Path
The path between two vertices in a graph that has the minimum sum of edge weights.
- Negative Edge Weight
An edge of a graph that adds a negative value to the total weight of a path.
- Negative Cycle
A cycle in a graph where the sum of the weights is negative, allowing for infinite decreases in path length.
- Relaxation
The process of updating the shortest path value for a vertex if a shorter path is found.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.