20 - Greedy Algorithms: Minimizing Lateness
Enroll to start learning
You’ve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
Introduction to Minimizing Lateness
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Today, we will discuss the Minimizing Lateness problem in scheduling. Can anyone tell me what minimizing lateness means in the context of job scheduling?
It means scheduling jobs so they finish by their deadlines without being late!
Exactly! We want to minimize the maximum amount of time by which jobs finish after their deadlines. Let's explore how this can be implemented with a greedy algorithm.
Examining Greedy Strategies
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
One initial thought might be to pick the shortest job first. What do you think would happen if we used this strategy?
It sounds good, but it might not always help since longer jobs could be more time-sensitive.
Correct! Let’s consider an example: If we have job 1 taking 1 unit of time with a deadline of 110, and job 2 taking 10 units of time with a deadline of 10, using the shortest job first results in lateness. Can you see why?
If we do job 1 first, job 2 finishes late!
The Effective Greedy Strategy
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
The effective strategy is to schedule jobs in order of their deadlines. Why do you think this works?
Because it prioritizes the jobs that need to finish soonest!
Exactly! We ensure no job waits unnecessarily, which prevents increased lateness. Let’s summarize how this impacts scheduling.
Proof of Optimality
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now, let’s discuss how we prove that scheduling jobs by deadlines is optimal. What do we mean by ‘no inversions’?
It means that a job with a later deadline can't be scheduled before a job with an earlier deadline.
Exactly! If we start with any optimal schedule, how could we ensure it involves no idle time?
Perhaps by shifting the jobs forward to fill gaps?
Yes! By applying these principles, we can establish that our greedy strategy leads to the best possible schedule.
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
The Minimizing Lateness problem examines scheduling requests to a single resource while minimizing the maximum lateness of jobs. It discusses various greedy strategies and provides a proof for the effectiveness of scheduling jobs by earliest deadlines.
Detailed
Greedy Algorithms: Minimizing Lateness
In this section, we address the Minimizing Lateness problem where, unlike previous scheduling problems that focused on start and finish times, we only have request durations and deadlines. Each job requires time t_i to complete by its corresponding deadline d_i. The goal is to minimize the maximum lateness across all jobs defined as the time by which a job's finish time exceeds its deadline.
Key Points Covered:
- Problem Definition: Each job has a completion time and a deadline. The task is to organize these jobs so that the maximum lateness is minimized.
- Greedy Strategies Considered:
- Shortest Job First: Initial intuition may lead to choosing jobs by shortest duration, but this can create cases of high lateness.
- Choosing by Slack: Selecting jobs with the least slack (i.e., deadline - duration) can also lead to suboptimal solutions.
- Optimal Strategy: The most effective greedy strategy is to sort jobs by their deadlines and process them in that order.
- Proof of Correctness: The section provides an exchange argument that shows the constructed schedule is optimal and does not contain inversions or idle time. Adjustments can be made to transform any optimal schedule into one based on the earliest deadline without increasing lateness.
This greedy approach leads to the conclusion that sorting jobs by deadline and processing them successively provides both an efficient algorithm and delivers optimal results.
Youtube Videos
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
Introduction to Minimizing Lateness
Chapter 1 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
In this section, we explore a different Greedy Algorithm, focusing on the problem of Minimizing Lateness. This problem involves scheduling requests that require time to complete and have deadlines.
Detailed Explanation
This introduction sets up the problem we need to solve, which is about scheduling jobs that have different durations and deadlines. Each job needs to be completed before its deadline to avoid being considered 'late'. The goal is to minimize the maximum amount of lateness across all jobs.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a student with multiple assignments due on different dates. Each assignment takes a certain number of hours to complete, and the student wants to finish all assignments as close to their deadlines as possible to avoid late penalties. This situation mirrors our Minimizing Lateness problem.
Understanding Job Scheduling
Chapter 2 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
For each request j, we define a start time s_j, the time it takes to process the request t_j, and a finish time f_j. If the finish time exceeds the deadline, the job is late, defined by the lateness l_j, which is the difference between the finish time and the deadline.
Detailed Explanation
Each job has a starting time and takes a specific time to complete. If the job finishes after its deadline, it is considered late. We define lateness as the amount of time by which it exceeds the deadline. This gives a measure of how well we are scheduling our jobs; our goal is to minimize the maximum lateness across all jobs.
Examples & Analogies
Think about a customer service department where each call (job) must be completed by a certain time (deadline). If the call goes over time, the department appears inefficient. The aim is to manage calls such that they finish on or before their deadlines, minimizing any delays.
First Greedy Strategy Attempt
Chapter 3 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
One naive greedy strategy is to schedule jobs based on shortest processing time first. However, this does not always yield optimal results. For example, if job 1 takes 1 time unit and job 2 takes 10 time units with deadlines 110 and 10 respectively, choosing the shortest job first leads to lateness.
Detailed Explanation
The first strategy tries to choose jobs that take the least time first, assuming this will yield better results. However, this example illustrates a scenario where this strategy fails. If we prioritize the shortest job, we can end up being late on another job that has a much stricter deadline, resulting in higher overall lateness.
Examples & Analogies
Consider a baker who needs to prioritize making several treats. If the baker focuses only on the quickest item to make, they might miss the deadline for a larger order that, while taking longer, needs to be completed sooner.
Second Strategy Consideration
Chapter 4 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Another approach considers prioritizing jobs based on how much time they can afford to be started late without missing their deadline (slack). However, this strategy also can lead to increased lateness, as shown in another analyzed example.
Detailed Explanation
This time, the strategy is to select jobs that have the least amount of slack, calculated by the difference between the deadline and the time required. However, through examples, it becomes clear that this does not lead to the minimum lateness we hope to achieve.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a project manager who assigns tasks based on how much extra time remains before the deadline. This can backfire if tasks that seem more flexible are actually critical to project success and need to be prioritized over seemingly urgent tasks.
Optimal Strategy: Earliest Deadline First
Chapter 5 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
The effective strategy that minimizes the maximum lateness is to schedule jobs by their deadlines, starting with the job with the earliest deadline first. This creates a straightforward job scheduling order.
Detailed Explanation
This strategy involves sorting the jobs by their deadlines and processing them in that order. This ensures that jobs with tighter deadlines are handled first, minimizing the risk of lateness because we are systematically addressing the most urgent tasks first.
Examples & Analogies
Think of organizing your day with appointments. If you have meetings with the closest deadlines first, you can ensure you're meeting your commitments effectively. Scheduling in this way prevents overlap and ensures timely completion.
Proof of Correctness via Exchange Argument
Chapter 6 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
To prove that scheduling jobs by earliest deadline yields an optimal solution, an exchange argument is used, showing that any scheduling with inversions (out-of-order jobs) can be transformed into one without inversions without increasing lateness.
Detailed Explanation
The proof utilizes the idea of inversions in job scheduling—if a job with a later deadline is placed before one with an earlier deadline, there exists a contradiction. By swapping such jobs while maintaining no gaps in the schedule, it’s shown that optimal scheduling is achievable, ensuring minimum lateness.
Examples & Analogies
This is like rearranging gears in a water wheel: if the arrangement is not optimal (where a slow gear is placed before a fast one), reordering those gears without creating downtime leads to a more efficient and quicker rotation of the wheel.
Conclusion on Algorithm Efficiency
Chapter 7 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
The implementation of the optimal strategy simply requires sorting the jobs by their deadlines followed by sequential scheduling. The time complexity is O(n log n) for sorting, and O(n) for the scheduling, summing to an effective n log n algorithm overall.
Detailed Explanation
The final part of the analysis conveys that after proving the correctness of the algorithm, we also analyze its efficiency. This is critical because it provides assurance that not only is the strategy correct, but it is feasible in terms of computational resources.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a restaurant setting up reservations: sorting them by time allows for a smooth dining experience without overlaps. It also shows that the sorting step can involve considerable effort, but ultimately leads to a smoother service overall.
Key Concepts
-
Greedy Strategy: A method that aims for local optimization in hopes of global optimization.
-
Earliest Deadline First: A scheduling strategy where jobs are organized according to their deadlines.
-
Maximal Lateness: The objective to minimize the latest finish time of all jobs past their deadlines.
Examples & Applications
Example 1: If Job 1 takes 1 unit of time with a deadline of 110 and Job 2 takes 10 units of time with a deadline of 10, scheduling Job 2 first causes lateness.
Example 2: Scheduling Job A with a 5-unit duration and deadline 15 before Job B with a 10-unit duration and deadline 20 results in an optimal schedule.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
When deadlines loom, we must consume, jobs in order to avoid the gloom.
Stories
A delivery truck named Tim received packages of different sizes; he learns the hard way that he must deliver smaller, urgent packages before the larger ones to avoid being late.
Memory Tools
To remember the job scheduling order: D for Deadline, O for Order, S for Schedule: 'DOS'.
Acronyms
G.E.A.R. (Greedy, Earliest deadline, Arrange jobs, Result)
quick guide to minimizing lateness.
Flash Cards
Glossary
- Lateness
The amount of time a job finishes past its deadline.
- Greedy Algorithm
An algorithm that makes the locally optimal choice at each stage in hopes of finding a global optimum.
- Slack
The amount of time that can be delayed before a job must start to meet its deadline.
- Inversion
A situation in a scheduling where a job with a later deadline is scheduled before a job with an earlier deadline.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.