Definition of Computable and Uncomputable Functions
Enroll to start learning
You’ve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
Introduction to Computable Functions
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Today, we will kick off by discussing computable functions. A function is computable if a computer program can determine its output for every potential input. Can anyone provide an example of a simple computable function?
How about the function that adds two numbers?
Great example! Adding two numbers is a computable function because we can write a clear algorithm that takes two inputs and produces a sum as an output. Remember, we denote a computable function as one that has a program executable in a programming language. Let's keep this in mind: **C for Computable = Clear Algorithm**.
Explaining Uncomputable Functions
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now, let's shift gears to uncomputable functions. These are functions for which no program exists that can compute their output for every input. Can anyone think of a potential example of an uncomputable function?
I read about the Halting Problem, where you can't determine whether a program will finish running or not.
Excellent! The Halting Problem is indeed a classic example of an uncomputable function. In these cases, no amount of resources or time can help us find a solution. That’s our memory aid: **U for Uncomputable = Unpredictable Outcome**.
Understanding Cardinality and Proofs
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
To prove that uncomputable functions exist, we use something called cardinality. We know that the collection of all programs is countable—this means we can list them out. What happens when we compare this to the functions mapping the positive integers to a set of limited integers?
Isn't it that there are more functions than there are programs?
Exactly! We demonstrate this through injective mapping. We can establish that the set of all real numbers is uncountable, leading us to conclude there's a disparity in cardinality, proving uncomputable functions exist. Remember, the key takeaway here is: **C for Countable = Can list it; U for Uncountable = Undefinable**.
Non-constructive Proofs
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
We often use non-constructive proofs when showing uncomputable functions exist. This means we are asserting the existence of a function without constructing it. Why would this be significant?
Because it shows limitations in computing without needing to specify an example?
Exactly! Non-constructive proofs underscore foundational limits in computer science. Let’s remember: **N for Non-constructive = Not an Example, but Existence**.
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
In this section, the concept of computable functions, defined as those that can be executed by a computer program for all inputs, is explored. It highlights the existence of uncomputable functions, demonstrated through cardinality arguments, emphasizing that certain functions cannot be computed regardless of the available resources.
Detailed
Definition of Computable and Uncomputable Functions
In the realm of discrete mathematics, understanding the distinction between computable and uncomputable functions is essential. A computable function can be described as a function for which a computer program exists that can determine the output for every possible input from the function's domain. The analysis does not concern itself with the efficiency or time it takes for the program to execute; rather, it focuses solely on the existence of such a program.
On the other hand, an uncomputable function is one for which no such program can be written, indicating that it cannot be computed under any circumstances, regardless of the time, resources, or memory dedicated to the task.
The section further establishes the existence of uncomputable functions by utilizing cardinality theory, specifically showing that the set of all functions from natural numbers to a finite set exceeds the countable set of programs representable in any programming language. This proof strategy employs a non-constructive approach, asserting the presence of uncomputable functions without necessarily identifying a concrete example. The significance lies in demonstrating inherent limitations of computation, suggesting that there are tasks that exceed the capability of any computer—a fundamental insight in computer science.
Youtube Videos
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
Introduction to Computable Functions
Chapter 1 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So what exactly are uncomputable functions; so they are some special type of functions. So say I have function f defined from a set X to a set Y then I will call the function f to be computable if there exists some computer program in a programming language which can compute or give you the value of this function for every possible input from the domain of that function.
Detailed Explanation
In this section, we discuss what computable functions are. A function 'f' is said to be computable if we can write a computer program that can calculate the value of 'f' for any valid input from its domain. This means that for every possible input value, the program should return an appropriate output value. It does not matter how long it takes or how much memory is used; the critical point is that a program exists to calculate 'f'.
Examples & Analogies
Think of a vending machine as a computable function. You can input a specific code for a drink, and the machine will provide you with that drink in exchange for money. No matter how many drinks the machine can offer (even different codes), if you have the correct code, you can always retrieve your drink.
Understanding Uncomputable Functions
Chapter 2 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
If you can write a program in the programming language for such a function I will call that function to be a computable function. Otherwise, I will call it an uncomputable function. So as per the above definition, a function which is not computable will be called an uncomputable function.
Detailed Explanation
Here we define uncomputable functions. A function is uncomputable if there is no program, regardless of resources like time or memory, that can compute it for every input. This means we cannot automate the calculation of its output through any conventional programming means.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine trying to predict the exact future of a complex ecosystem purely based on current data. No matter how advanced your computer is or how much information it has, some outcomes may still be impossible to predict accurately due to the numerous unpredictable variables involved.
The Existence of Uncomputable Functions
Chapter 3 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So what we now want to prove is that there indeed exists uncomputable function that means it does not matter how much resources time and memory space you provide.
Detailed Explanation
The lecture proposes to prove that uncomputable functions exist by showing that while there are infinitely many programs, they cannot account for all possible functions. For instance, the set of all valid programs can be counted (enumerated) while the set of all functions may be larger, leading to uncomputable functions.
Examples & Analogies
Think of a library. It has a certain number of books (valid programs). Now imagine an infinite collection of different stories (possible functions). While you can have an infinite number of stories, there aren’t enough books to hold them all if the library has a limited shelf space dedicated for them—this means some stories (functions) cannot be written down (computed).
Cardinality of Functions vs. Programs
Chapter 4 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
When I say programs I mean to say the valid programs; which complies and give you an output. That means it has a begin instruction and an end instruction and a sequence of arbitrary number of instructions in between the begin and end instructions and it complies and it gives you an output.
Detailed Explanation
This segment explains the structure of valid programs that can be counted or enumerated. While it's possible to count valid programs, the number of potential functions between sets may vastly exceed this count. Thus, even with infinitely many programs, some functions remain outside their reach, establishing the existence of uncomputable functions.
Examples & Analogies
Consider a recipe book filled with finite recipes (valid programs). Each recipe can produce a dish (function). No matter how many recipes are available, there are countless dishes that could exist (potential functions). This means that not every possible dish can be made with the recipes in the book, leading to 'dishes' that can't be easily created (uncomputable functions).
Non-Constructive Proof of Uncomputability
Chapter 5 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So our proof strategy will involve showing there exists at least one uncomputable function using a non-constructive approach.
Detailed Explanation
In this part, the speaker introduces the proof strategy. The proof will be non-constructive, meaning instead of providing a specific example of an uncomputable function, it will logically demonstrate that at least one must exist. This type of proof is commonly used for existential statements, showing that the boundaries of computability are broader than initially perceived.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a treasure map leading to a single treasure chest with no boundaries specified—only the existence of the treasure is acknowledged. You're not given where it is but are told it exists. The treasure is akin to finding at least one uncomputable function that cannot be explicitly identified but is proven to exist through logical reasoning.
Conclusively Establishing Uncountability
Chapter 6 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
We will show that the cardinality of this collection of all possible functions is not א0.
Detailed Explanation
In this section, the aim is to show that the number of possible functions (from the set of positive integers to digits) is more than the count of valid programs. This is crucial because if valid programs (countable) are fewer than possible functions (which could be uncountable), it logically leads to the conclusion that uncomputable functions exist.
Examples & Analogies
Picture trying to match every student (valid programs) in a school to every type of music they might enjoy (possible functions). If there are more music genres than students, inevitably, some music genres will not find a student who likes them. This scenario mirrors why some functions remain uncomputable—they simply do not have the right program to compute them.
Key Concepts
-
Computable Functions: Functions that have corresponding computer programs able to compute their outputs for any input.
-
Uncomputable Functions: Functions without any computer program that can compute their outputs for every input.
-
Cardinality: The concept used to measure the 'size' of sets, crucial for understanding computability.
-
Non-constructive Proofs: Proofs that establish the existence of an object without constructing a specific example.
Examples & Applications
An example of a computable function is f(x) = x^2, where a program can be written to compute this for any natural number input.
The Halting Problem showcases an uncomputable function where it is impossible to determine if an arbitrary program will halt or run forever.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
In the world of code and function's flow, / Some can compute, some can’t, you know.
Stories
Once in a coding land, there was a castle filled with programs. The wise wizard said, 'Some functions can be harnessed, while others remain mysterious, forever uncatchable, like the whispers of the wind.'
Memory Tools
C for Clear Algorithms (Computable) and U for Unpredictable Outcomes (Uncomputable).
Acronyms
F-U-C (Functions - Uncomputable - Computable) to remember the main ideas!
Flash Cards
Glossary
- Computable Function
A function for which a computer program can compute an output for every input within its domain.
- Uncomputable Function
A function for which no program can be constructed that computes an output for every input.
- Cardinality
A measure of the 'number of elements' in a set, used to compare sizes of sets.
- Nonconstructive Proof
A proof that establishes the existence of a mathematical object without providing a concrete example.
- Halting Problem
A specific example of an uncomputable function concerning whether a program will finish running or run indefinitely.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.