Closure Problem
Enroll to start learning
You’ve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
Understanding the Closure Problem
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Today, we will explore the Closure Problem, which is a critical aspect of modeling turbulent flows in CFD. Can anyone tell me what this problem is about?
Is it about how we deal with fluctuations in flow?
Exactly! The Closure Problem revolves around modeling the Reynolds shear stress, which signifies fluctuations. Remember, shear stress is important for predicting average velocity and pressure in a fluid.
How do we express these fluctuations in our equations?
Good question, let’s focus on expressing the Reynolds shear stress as a function of average flow properties to remove fluctuations systematically.
To remember this, think of the acronym R.E.M. for 'Remove fluctuations, Express averages, Model accurately'.
So, it’s about making our calculations manageable?
Correct! To summarize, the Closure Problem is about simplifying the complex dynamics of turbulence so that we can achieve accurate modeling in hydraulic engineering.
The k-epsilon Model
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now let's dive into one of the solutions to the Closure Problem, the k-epsilon model. Can anyone explain what 'k' and 'epsilon' represent?
I think 'k' is kinetic energy?
That's right! 'k' represents turbulent kinetic energy, while 'epsilon' represents the rate of energy dissipation. Together, they help us model the turbulent flows accurately.
How do we use these parameters in our equations?
"For modeling, we derive expressions for k and epsilon based on the averages we calculate from our flow data. Let’s also remember that the relationship of $
Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS)
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Finally, let's discuss Direct Numerical Simulation, or DNS. Can anyone tell me how it differs from the k-epsilon model?
Doesn't DNS not use turbulence models?
Exactly! DNS solves the Navier-Stokes equations directly without the assumption of turbulence models. This allows it to capture the exact dynamics of flows.
But why don’t we use it all the time then?
That's a great observation! It requires extremely high computational resources, which can be a limitation in practice. Think about how many grid points we might need based on Reynolds numbers!
Use 'High Power Needs' to remember the high cost of computations in DNS.
So, DNS is powerful, but not always practical?
Precisely! In summary, DNS offers accuracy but at a computationally expensive price. Meanwhile, models like k-epsilon provide manageable equations for practical application.
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
This section discusses the Closure Problem in Computational Fluid Dynamics, particularly in hydraulic engineering. It highlights the importance of modeling Reynolds shear stress to derive average flow velocities and pressure from Reynolds-averaged equations, utilizing specific turbulence models like the k-epsilon model and k-omega model while also acknowledging alternatives like Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS).
Detailed
Detailed Summary
The Closure Problem arises in the field of Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD), particularly when dealing with turbulent flows. It focuses on the modeling of Reynolds shear stress ($
ho au_{ij}$), which plays a crucial role in predicting the mean flow characteristics of a fluid. The crucial challenge is to express $
ho au_{ij}$ as a function of average flow properties, allowing for the removal of fluctuations typically present in turbulent flows.
To tackle this problem, various models are utilized, with the k-epsilon model being the most prevalent. This model examines how turbulent kinetic energy is affected by fluctuations in the fluid's properties. The equation consolidates the mean kinetic energy and the turbulent kinetic energy to represent an overall energy profile of the flow.
The section details the equations involved in computing the average flow behaviors, including the continuity equation and the momentum equations. It describes the turbulent kinematic viscosity ($
u_t$), a vital component of the model, which relates to the energy dissipation rate and turbulent energy. $
u_t$ is derived from well-established experimental constants, streamlining the modeling process.
An alternative approach, Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS), is mentioned, which involves simulating the governing equations of turbulent flows without turbulence models, focusing on achieving highly accurate solutions. However, the need for extensive computational power poses significant challenges.
In summary, this section describes how understanding and resolving the Closure Problem is essential for making accurate predictions in hydraulic engineering applications.
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
Understanding Reynolds Shear Stress
Chapter 1 of 5
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
The effect of rho in tau i j is actually Reynolds shear stress. So it is like shear stress to obtain u i and pressure. So, u i is the average flow velocities and pressure from RANS equation, we need to model this shear stress rho in tau i j as a function of the average flow.
Detailed Explanation
In fluid dynamics, Reynolds shear stress is an important concept that modifies the way we predict the behavior of fluid flow. It introduces a correction factor to the average flow calculations. The term 'tau i j' denotes the stress in the fluid, influenced by turbulence, while 'rho' represents fluid density. Here, 'u i' indicates the average velocity of the fluid.
To accurately describe turbulent flows, we want to relate this shear stress to measurable quantities, specifically to the average flow parameters. This is vital for practical applications since turbulence can significantly impact fluid motion and the resultant forces on structures.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine driving through a crowded street. The average speed of cars (u i) fluctuates due to traffic jams and different driving behaviors, much like how turbulent flows behave in a fluid. Just as you need to understand these averages to estimate your arrival time, engineers must understand Reynolds shear stress to predict how fluids will behave under different conditions.
Defining the Closure Problem
Chapter 2 of 5
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
This particular problem is called a closure problem. To obtain u i and pressure from Reynolds equation, we need to model this Reynolds's shear stress given by rho into tau i j as a function of average flow, this will remove the fluctuations.
Detailed Explanation
The closure problem arises from the need to express turbulent stresses (like Reynolds shear stress) in terms of mean quantities that can be more easily estimated or calculated. In turbulence modeling, we treat the known average flow parameters as the starting point and seek to express the unknown turbulent effects (the closures) in terms of these averaged values. By successfully modeling these stresses, engineers can predict fluid behavior without needing to capture every little fluctuation in the flow.
Examples & Analogies
Consider a classroom with students varying in their heights – if you want to estimate the average height of the class (closure), you measure each student but need to account for the outliers (very short or very tall students) that could skew your average. Similarly, in fluid dynamics, while we can measure the average flow, we also need a good model to account for the unpredictable turbulence.
The k-epsilon Model
Chapter 3 of 5
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
The first of the methods is called the k epsilon model. In this technique, the model focuses on the mechanism that affects the turbulent kinetic energy, k stands for kinetic energy.
Detailed Explanation
The k-epsilon model is a widely used turbulence model in computational fluid dynamics. Here, 'k' represents the turbulent kinetic energy of a flow, while 'epsilon' indicates the rate at which this energy is dissipated. This model helps bridge the gap between observable mean flows and complex turbulence by relating the average kinetic energy and its dissipation, making it easier to compute fluid behavior under various conditions.
Examples & Analogies
Think about how a group of friends plays around in a park (turbulence). Some friends are more energetic (k) and will eventually tire out (epsilon). If we want to know how much energy they exert over time, we consider both their current activity (energy) and how quickly they tire (dissipation), similar to how engineers use the k-epsilon model to predict turbulent flows.
Eddy Viscosity and Turbulent Energy
Chapter 4 of 5
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
This nu t is the eddy viscosity. This actually is better called as turbulent eddy viscosity, nu T, it can be dimensionally related to kinetic energy k kinetic energy dissipation rate epsilon through nu T is written as c mu into k square by epsilon.
Detailed Explanation
Eddy viscosity (nu t) is a measure of the effective viscosity in turbulent flows. It accounts for the mixing and momentum transfer due to eddies (or swirling motions) within the fluid. The relationship nu T = c mu * (k^2/epsilon) links eddy viscosity to turbulent kinetic energy and its dissipation rate, helping to quantify how turbulence affects flow characteristics.
Examples & Analogies
Consider stirring a thick soup. As you stir, you create swirling motions that mix the ingredients more effectively than if you just let them sit. The 'thickness' of the soup can be thought of as viscosity. Just as stirring (eddy viscosity) mixes the soup (momentum transfer), turbulent eddies mix a fluid, making flow predictions more complex yet more accurate.
Solving for Turbulence Parameters
Chapter 5 of 5
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, the next step is finding out this turbulent kinetic energy k and epsilon that that is how this equation gets in the model gets its name. And to be able to do that we have two other equations - one is in terms of kinetic energy and one is in terms of epsilon.
Detailed Explanation
To solve the closure problem, we need to derive equations to calculate both turbulent kinetic energy (k) and the dissipation rate (epsilon). These equations use variables derived from the flow characteristics. Solving these equations allows us to estimate how energy is produced and dissipated in the turbulence, thereby enabling better predictions of flow behavior.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine trying to predict how fast a campfire will burn out using knowledge of how much wood (energy) is available (k) and how quickly it turns to ash (epsilon) once consumed. By understanding both how flames burn and how they weaken, you can effectively manage the fire, similar to managing turbulence in fluid flows.
Key Concepts
-
Closure Problem: The issue of modeling Reynolds shear stress to simplify turbulent flows.
-
Reynolds Shear Stress: A key factor in predicting average flow properties.
-
k-epsilon Model: A widely used turbulence model that simplifies calculations by estimating turbulent effects.
-
Direct Numerical Simulation: An accurate, but computationally expensive method for simulating turbulent flows.
Examples & Applications
The k-epsilon model is often used in environmental engineering to predict pollutant dispersion in water bodies.
A DNS approach might be employed in high-fidelity simulations of airflows around aircraft wings to ensure precise predictions.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
In the flow, if all is not clear, the Closure Problem draws near, shear stress we must trace, for average flows to embrace.
Stories
Imagine a turbulent river where the flow is wavy, and every ripple brings uncertainty. To navigate, engineers use powerful tools like the k-epsilon model, much like a map, guiding them to find the smoothest path—our key to fluid dynamics.
Memory Tools
R.E.M. - Remove fluctuations, Express averages, Model accurately.
Acronyms
H.P.N. - High Power Needs for Direct Numerical Simulation.
Flash Cards
Glossary
- Closure Problem
A challenge in turbulent fluid flow calculations related to modeling the Reynolds shear stress to account for fluctuations.
- Reynolds Shear Stress
A measure of the forces in a turbulent fluid flow, critical for predicting mean velocities and pressure.
- kepsilon Model
A turbulence model focusing on kinetic energy and its dissipation to model turbulent flow behavior.
- Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS)
A computational approach that directly solves the Navier-Stokes equations without turbulence models to simulate fluid flows.
- Turbulent Eddy Viscosity
A parameter representing the eddy viscosity effects in turbulent flows, essential for modeling the shear stress.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.