4.1.4 - Comparison of Frame structures with Normal Load bearing Traditional High Rise Building
Enroll to start learning
You’ve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
Understanding Frame Structures
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Today, we're going to delve into why frame structures are often preferred for high-rise buildings compared to traditional load-bearing structures. Can anyone tell me what they think makes frame structures stand out?
Maybe it's because they're lighter and more flexible?
Exactly! Frame structures are indeed more flexible. This flexibility significantly aids in supporting heavy loads without the need for massive walls. Recall, flexibility can help mitigate damage during events like earthquakes. Remember the acronym 'FLEX'—Flexible, Lighter, Efficient, eXtra adaptive.
Are there any disadvantages to using frame structures?
Good question! While they have advantages, frame structures can still face challenges, especially regarding lateral deflections over large spans. Always important to balance the design!
Challenges of Load-Bearing Structures
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Let's talk about traditional load-bearing structures. What do you all think are some challenges they face?
I think they need thicker walls, which would cost more and take longer to build.
Exactly! That increase in wall thickness leads to higher material costs and labor, ultimately slowing down construction speed. Remember: 'THICK'—Time-consuming, Heavy, Increased Cost, Keep walls thicker. This makes it less efficient than frame structures.
And they’re not as adaptable, right? You can’t change them easily.
Correct! Rehabilitating a load-bearing structure is far more complex compared to a frame structure that can easily accommodate changes and updates.
Economic Benefits of Frame Structures
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
What about the economic benefits? How do frame structures save money in the long run?
They probably reduce material costs since they don’t need as much structure as load-bearing buildings.
Exactly! Their lightweight construction requires less material, which also brings down overall costs. Also, frame structures allow for different services to be added later, which means less remodeling. Think of the acronym 'COST'—Construction Optimized, Savings on Time.
So, it’s not just about the initial cost but also about saving future costs?
That's right! Initial investment is just one part; the long-term operational costs are also critical. Flexibility in design can lead to savings down the road.
Rehabilitation of Frame Structures
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Let’s explore how frame structures can be rehabilitated compared to load-bearing structures. Why is rehabilitation easier with frame structures?
I think it's because they're not as tied down by the structure itself?
Exactly! Frame structures are versatile, allowing for easy modification and upgrades as per requirements whereas load-bearing walls often restrict changes.
That must also save a lot of time and money, right?
Absolutely! And don’t forget the mnemonic 'MODIFY'—Modular, Organized, Dynamic, Innovative, Flexible, Yours. This encapsulates why frame structures excel in adaptability.
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
The comparison highlights how frame structures offer superior flexibility and accompanying economic benefits compared to traditional load-bearing structures. The section emphasizes the challenges faced by load-bearing structures, such as increased mass leading to thicker walls and higher costs, whereas frame structures are designed for efficiency and adaptability.
Detailed
The selected frame structures for high-rise buildings showcase a significant advantage over traditional load-bearing constructions, primarily due to their versatility and efficiency. Load-bearing structures typically require greater mass, which translates to the necessity for thicker walls and wider structural elements, leading to more labor-intensive construction and increased costs. In contrast, frame structures provide enhanced flexibility, allowing for significant load-bearing capacity while utilizing less material and labor. Furthermore, frame structures can adapt over time, integrating new services and rehabilitations more seamlessly than their traditional counterparts.
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
Performance Dependency of Load Bearing Structures
Chapter 1 of 2
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Actually, the performance of load bearing structures is usually dependent on the mass of structures. To fulfill this requirement of load bearing structures, there is the need of increase in volume of structural elements (walls, slab). This increase in volume of the structural elements leads toward the construction of thick wall. Due to such a type of construction, labor and construction cost increases. In construction of thick wall there will be the need of great attention, which will further reduce the speed of construction.
Detailed Explanation
Load bearing structures rely heavily on their mass to support the weight of the building. This means that to ensure stability, the volume of structural components like walls and slabs must be increased. This often requires building thicker walls, which can lead to higher costs in labor and materials. Thick walls take longer to construct because they require meticulous attention to detail during the building process, ultimately slowing down the overall timeline of the construction project.
Examples & Analogies
Think of building a sandcastle at the beach. If you want your castle to stand tall and resist the waves, you need to use more sand and pack it tightly. This way, the castle can withstand the force of the water. However, piling on more and more sand takes time and effort, just like constructing thick walls in buildings requires more labor and slows down progress.
Advantages of Framed Structures
Chapter 2 of 2
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
If we make the contrast of load bearing structures with the framed structures, framed structures appear to be more flexible, economical and can carry the heavy loads. Frame structures can be rehabilitated at any time. Different services can be provided in frame structures. Thus the frame structures are flexible in use.
Detailed Explanation
Framed structures are generally more advantageous than load-bearing structures due to their flexibility and cost-effectiveness. Unlike traditional load-bearing walls that are rigid, framed structures can adapt to changes. They can be modified or rehabilitated over time without needing to reinforce the entire structure. Additionally, they can support significant loads and allow for various utilities and services (like electrical wiring and plumbing) to be integrated seamlessly into the design.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a Lego building compared to a sand structure. The Lego building can easily be modified, expanded, or dismantled without damaging the other parts. You can add windows or doors at any time. In contrast, once you've built a sand structure, changing it can be messy and usually requires tearing down the whole thing. This illustrates the inherent flexibility and adaptability of framed structures.
Key Concepts
-
Frame Structures: Comprised of beams, columns, and slabs designed to bear loads more efficiently than traditional structures.
-
Load Bearing Structures: Typically require additional material and mass, leading to increased costs and limitations in design.
-
Economic Efficiency: Frame structures are generally less expensive to construct and rehabilitate, providing long-term cost benefits.
-
Rehabilitation Flexibility: Frame structures offer greater flexibility for future changes and upgrades compared to load-bearing structures.
Examples & Applications
Burj Al-Arab, a famous high-rise building, utilizes rigid frame structures for increased stability and load-bearing capacity.
Gabled frame structures are lightweight, significantly reducing impacts during seismic events.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
Load-bearing walls make buildings slow, while frame structures let flexibility flow.
Stories
Imagine a builder faced with two challenges: a frame structure that can easily be altered and a load-bearing wall that is tough to modify. The builder chooses the flexible option!
Memory Tools
Use 'FLEX' for Frame structures: Flexible, Lighter, Efficient, eXtra adaptive.
Acronyms
THICK
Time-consuming
Heavy
Increased Cost
Keep walls thicker for load-bearing structures.
Flash Cards
Glossary
- Frame Structure
A structure composed of beams, columns, and slabs designed to support loads efficiently.
- Load Bearing Structure
A building structure that supports its own weight as well as the loads applied through walls and slabs.
- Flexibility
The ability of a structure to withstand deformation or changes in load without failing.
- Rehabilitation
The process of restoring or updating an existing structure to improve its performance or functionality.
- Economical
Relating to the efficient use of resources to achieve cost savings.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.