Learn
Games

7.3.4 - Limitations of Concept of Oxidation Number

Interactive Audio Lesson

Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.

Introduction to Oxidation Numbers

Unlock Audio Lesson

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Lesson

Teacher
Teacher

Today, we're going to explore oxidation numbers, particularly the concept of fractional oxidation numbers. Can anyone tell me what an oxidation number is?

Student 1
Student 1

Isn't it the charge an atom would have if all bonds were ionic?

Teacher
Teacher

Exactly! Oxidation numbers help us determine how electrons are transferred in redox reactions. But what happens when we encounter fractions in these oxidation numbers?

Student 2
Student 2

I think it sounds confusing! How can an atom have a fractional charge?

Teacher
Teacher

Great question! The fractions represent average oxidation states when there are atoms in different oxidation states within a compound. For example, consider C3O2.

Student 3
Student 3

What’s special about C3O2?

Teacher
Teacher

In C3O2, two carbon atoms are at +2 and one at 0. Therefore the average oxidation number for carbon comes out to be 4/3. This isn't how it exists structurally; it's an average based on the number of different states.

Student 4
Student 4

Oh, so it's like getting an average score in a game!

Teacher
Teacher

Exactly! Now let's summarize key points: fractional oxidation numbers reflect averages due to varying states in structure rather than actual electrons

Examining Structural Parameters

Unlock Audio Lesson

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Lesson

Teacher
Teacher

Now, let's continue about how structural parameters come into play in understanding fractional oxidation numbers. Can anyone give me an example of a compound with fractional oxidation states?

Student 2
Student 2

What about Br3O8? I remember it was mentioned!

Teacher
Teacher

That's correct! Br3O8 includes terminal bromines in a +6 state and a central bromine in a +4 state, resulting in an average of 16/3. But tell me, how does knowing the structure help us?

Student 1
Student 1

It shows where each atom actually is and what its real state is, right?

Teacher
Teacher

Yes! The structure reveals the reality; averages can mislead us if we don't consider them in a structural context.

Student 3
Student 3

So, we need to visualize molecules to truly understand their behavior?

Teacher
Teacher

Exactly! Always remember the phrase 'Structure reveals reality' as a mnemonic. Now, let’s recap what we've learned about average oxidation states and the importance of their structural representation.

Practical Implications of Fractional States

Unlock Audio Lesson

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Lesson

Teacher
Teacher

Moving on, why do we even care about fractional oxidation numbers in practical chemistry?

Student 4
Student 4

Maybe because they tell us how certain elements will behave in reactions?

Teacher
Teacher

Absolutely! The way we apply this knowledge can affect industries like pharmaceuticals and materials science.

Student 2
Student 2

So if we misinterpret fractional states, we might create ineffective products?

Teacher
Teacher

Exactly! Misunderstanding can lead to flawed predictions in reactions. What’s a final takeaway we should remember?

Student 1
Student 1

That we need to consider both average oxidation numbers and structures together!

Teacher
Teacher

Well said! Always integrate structure with oxidation state understanding in your studies. This will help solidify your grasp of redox chemistry.

Introduction & Overview

Read a summary of the section's main ideas. Choose from Basic, Medium, or Detailed.

Quick Overview

This section explores the concept of fractional oxidation numbers in compounds, addressing the apparent contradictions and clarifying how structural parameters reveal the reality of mixed oxidation states.

Standard

The section discusses the phenomenon of fractional oxidation numbers found in certain compounds, such as C3O2 and Br3O8. It explains that these fractions represent average oxidation states and emphasizes the importance of structural analysis to understand the actual oxidation states of elements, which often differ from the calculated averages.

Detailed

The Paradox of Fractional Oxidation Number

The concept of oxidation numbers is crucial in understanding redox reactions. Generally, oxidation states are whole numbers. However, certain compounds exhibit fractional oxidation states, leading to confusion and paradoxes. For instance, in compounds like C3O2, Br3O8, and Na2S4O6, the oxidation numbers of some elements are calculated to be fractions such as 4/3 or 2.5. This section critically examines the origin and implications of fractional oxidation numbers while emphasizing the structural dynamics that clarify these states.

Fractional Oxidation Numbers Explained

Fractional oxidation states indicate average oxidation states derived from the presence of multiple oxidation states in a compound. For example:
- In C3O2, two carbon atoms are in a +2 oxidation state, while one carbon atom is in a zero oxidation state. The average oxidation state of carbon in the compound is thus 4/3.
- Similarly, the average oxidation states of bromine in Br3O8 can be represented as 16/3, considering two terminal bromine atoms in a +6 oxidation state and the central bromine in a +4 state.
- For Na2S4O6, the average oxidation number of sulfur is shown as 2.5, where two sulfur atoms are +5 and two are 0.

Significance

The significance of this analysis lies in the transition from theoretical calculations to practical understanding; it highlights that fractional oxidation states should be treated carefully, as they only reflect average states rather than definitive quantities. To appreciate the complexity of oxidation states, consideration of molecular structure is vital, revealing the real distribution of electrons in different oxidation states.

Youtube Videos

Tricks to find oxidation state | Redox Reactions | Class 11 chemistry | Narendra Sir (IITB 2003)
Tricks to find oxidation state | Redox Reactions | Class 11 chemistry | Narendra Sir (IITB 2003)
[WOW] redox reaction between Iron and copper ions #shorts
[WOW] redox reaction between Iron and copper ions #shorts
How To Calculate Oxidation Number or Oxidation State? Easy Trick
How To Calculate Oxidation Number or Oxidation State? Easy Trick
Chemistry Redox Reaction part 2 (Oxidation Definition) CBSE class 11 XI
Chemistry Redox Reaction part 2 (Oxidation Definition) CBSE class 11 XI
Redox Reactions Class 11 | Chemistry Complete Chapter
Redox Reactions Class 11 | Chemistry Complete Chapter
Class 11 chap 8 | Redox Reactions 01 : How to Find Oxidation Number- Methods n Tricks JEE MAINS/NEET
Class 11 chap 8 | Redox Reactions 01 : How to Find Oxidation Number- Methods n Tricks JEE MAINS/NEET
Starch Indicator and Limitations of Oxidation Number - Redox Reactions #17
Starch Indicator and Limitations of Oxidation Number - Redox Reactions #17
Redox Reaction Lecture 01 | Oxidation Number Chemistry Class for 11th Class | Science and Fun
Redox Reaction Lecture 01 | Oxidation Number Chemistry Class for 11th Class | Science and Fun
REDOX reaction between manganese and hydrogen peroxide #shorts #chemistry
REDOX reaction between manganese and hydrogen peroxide #shorts #chemistry
Oxidation and Reduction Reactions
Oxidation and Reduction Reactions

Audio Book

Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.

Introduction to Fractional Oxidation Numbers

Unlock Audio Book

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Book

Sometimes, we come across with certain compounds in which the oxidation number of a particular element in the compound is in fraction. Examples are:
C₃O₂ [where oxidation number of carbon is (4/3)],
Br₃O₈ [where oxidation number of bromine is (16/3)]
and Na₂S₄O₆ (where oxidation number of sulphur is 2.5).

Detailed Explanation

In some chemical compounds, the oxidation states of elements do not result in whole numbers but fractions. For example, in C₃O₂, carbon has an average oxidation state of 4/3, indicating that not all carbon atoms are in the same oxidation state. Similarly, in Br₃O₈, bromine has an average of 16/3, and in Na₂S₄O₆, sulfur has an average oxidation number of 2.5. These fractions indicate that within the compounds, the element exhibits multiple oxidation states.

Examples & Analogies

Think of a classroom where two students are always at the top of their class, while one student usually struggles with grades. If we calculated the average test score for the three, it wouldn’t exactly reflect the individual performance, but rather, it combines their scores into a broader view. Similarly, fractional oxidation numbers provide an average which can help to understand the behavior of elements in compounds better.

Understanding Fractional Oxidation States

Unlock Audio Book

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Book

We know that the idea of fractional oxidation number is unconvincing to us, because electrons are never shared/transferred in fraction. Actually this fractional oxidation state is the average oxidation state of the element under examination and the structural parameters reveal that the element for whom fractional oxidation state is realised is present in different oxidation states.

Detailed Explanation

The concept of fractional oxidation states might seem confusing as it implies that electrons are shared or transferred in parts, which is not the case in reality. Instead, the fractional oxidation numbers indicate that an element is present in multiple oxidation states in a compound. For example, the structure of C₃O₂ shows that out of three carbon atoms, two have a +2 oxidation state and one has a 0 state, resulting in an average of +4/3. The actual states of the atoms reveal the complexity behind the fractional number.

Examples & Analogies

Imagine a basketball team where some players score high points in certain games, while others have lower scores. If we average their scores, one player may have a score of 30 points in one game and 10 in another, resulting in an average of 20. However, this average does not reflect their individual game performances accurately. Similarly, fractional oxidation numbers give an average rather than a complete picture of electron states.

Structures Indicating Fractional States

Unlock Audio Book

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Book

Structure of the species C₃O₂, Br₃O₈ and S₄O₆²⁻ reveal the following bonding situations:

          +2    0    +2

O = C = C* = C = O
Structure of C₃O₂ (carbon suboxide)
Structure of Br₃O₈ (tribromooctaoxide) Structure of S₄O₆²⁻ (tetrathionate ion)

Detailed Explanation

The structures of these compounds provide insight into how different oxidation states exist within a single species. In C₃O₂, two carbon atoms are bonded in a +2 oxidation state, while the central carbon exists in a 0 state. Similarly, in Br₃O₈, terminal bromines hold a +6 state, while the middle bromine has a +4 oxidation state. For the tetrathionate ion S₄O₆²⁻, external sulfur atoms show a +5 state while internal ones are at 0. This variability highlights that while the average may suggest a fraction, actual bonding reveals whole numbers.

Examples & Analogies

Consider a fruit salad with various fruits mixed together. While the salad overall represents a mix of flavors, each fruit maintains its unique taste. The average flavor profile of the salad may be appealing, but it’s the distinct flavors of each fruit that truly create the dish. Similarly, the complex structures of compounds containing fractional oxidation numbers reveal their distinct oxidation states, clarifying the overall 'flavor' of the compound's oxidation state.

Conclusion on Fractional Oxidation Number

Unlock Audio Book

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Book

We may thus, in general, conclude that the idea of fractional oxidation state should be taken with care and the reality is revealed by the structures only. Further, whenever we come across with fractional oxidation state of any particular element in any species, we must understand that this is the average oxidation number only. In reality (revealed by structures only), the element in that particular species is present in more than one whole number oxidation states.

Detailed Explanation

In conclusion, the fractional oxidation numbers are useful for providing an average but should be interpreted carefully. The true oxidation states can only be understood through the structural representations, which reveal that the elements often exist in multiple oxidation states within a compound. Recognizing this helps us effectively grasp the chemistry behind various compounds and their properties.

Examples & Analogies

Think of a company's employees sharing average salaries. The average might be useful, yet it doesn't reflect the individual salaries of high earners and low earners in the team. Just as understanding these individual salaries gives clearer insight into company dynamics, examining oxidation states through structure offers a truer picture of the element's behavior in compounds.

Definitions & Key Concepts

Learn essential terms and foundational ideas that form the basis of the topic.

Key Concepts

  • Fractional Oxidation Numbers: Average oxidation states calculated for elements in compounds with various oxidation states.

  • Structural Analysis: The real oxidation states are revealed through understanding of molecular structure.

Examples & Real-Life Applications

See how the concepts apply in real-world scenarios to understand their practical implications.

Examples

  • In C3O2, the oxidation number for carbon averages to 4/3 due to the presence of carbon atoms in different oxidation states.

  • In Br3O8, the average oxidation number for bromine is 16/3, with two bromine atoms in +6 state and one in +4.

Memory Aids

Use mnemonics, acronyms, or visual cues to help remember key information more easily.

🎵 Rhymes Time

  • Fractional states, averages made, understand the structure to see the truth displayed.

📖 Fascinating Stories

  • Imagine a school team where two players are in top form while one is not, the average score reflects their combined performance but doesn't show the actual state of each player.

🧠 Other Memory Gems

  • FACES: Fractional Average Charges Equal Structures.

🎯 Super Acronyms

FOS – Fractional Oxidation State shows averages.

Flash Cards

Review key concepts with flashcards.

Glossary of Terms

Review the Definitions for terms.

  • Term: Oxidation Number

    Definition:

    The charge an atom would have if all bonds were ionic.

  • Term: Fractional Oxidation Number

    Definition:

    An average oxidation state of an atom calculated in compounds where atoms exist in different oxidation states.

  • Term: Average Oxidation State

    Definition:

    The mean value of the oxidation states of an element when it exists in multiple oxidation states within a compound.

  • Term: Structural Parameters

    Definition:

    Aspects of a molecule's structure that influence its chemical behavior and properties.