Learn
Games

3.1.4 - A new system is devised

Interactive Audio Lesson

Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.

Introduction to the New Revenue Systems

Unlock Audio Lesson

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Lesson

Teacher
Teacher

Alright class, today we're diving into the new systems of revenue collection devised by the East India Company. Can anyone tell me why the Permanent Settlement was problematic?

Student 1
Student 1

It was fixed and didn't allow for any changes, which made it hard for zamindars to pay.

Teacher
Teacher

Exactly! The rigid nature of fixed revenue led to issues when the Company needed more funds. So, Holt Mackenzie introduced the mahalwari system. Let's highlight this: M-A-H-A-L-W-A-R-I represents 'Modern Assessment, Headman Authority, Local Welfare, and Regular Inspection.' This acronym can help you remember its major principles. Who can explain this system further?

Student 2
Student 2

The village headman collected taxes instead of the zamindar?

Teacher
Teacher

Right! This made revenue more manageable for peasant farmers. What else changed?

Student 3
Student 3

The revenue isn't fixed permanently.

Teacher
Teacher

Great! By adjusting revenue demands, the Company aimed to make it easier for the villagers. Are there any questions about how this system was structured?

Student 4
Student 4

What challenges did these new systems face?

Teacher
Teacher

That's an excellent question! We'll touch on that shortly. For now, think about how effective this new approach was.

Details of the Mahalwari Settlement

Unlock Audio Lesson

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Lesson

Teacher
Teacher

Let’s explore the mahalwari settlement in detail. Can someone explain the main procedures that collectors had to follow under this system?

Student 1
Student 1

They had to inspect the villages and measure fields.

Teacher
Teacher

Correct! They documented customs and rights of various groups as well. This personalized approach aimed to stabilize agriculture. Why do you think this was necessary?

Student 3
Student 3

Because it encouraged more investment in agriculture.

Teacher
Teacher

Exactly! The more people felt they owned their land, the more likely they were to invest in it. However, as the assessment became periodic, did this ensure fairness?

Student 2
Student 2

Not if the officials still set high demands.

Teacher
Teacher

Spot on! This situation sometimes led to peasants facing difficulties. Now, let’s move on to the ryotwari system next.

The Ryotwari System

Unlock Audio Lesson

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Lesson

Teacher
Teacher

Transitioning away from the mahalwari, let’s look at the ryotwari system. How did it differ from the mahalwari system?

Student 1
Student 1

It dealt directly with the cultivators.

Teacher
Teacher

Correct! This system recognized individual rights of ryots to the land and required a personal contract. Why might this encourage greater responsibility?

Teacher
Teacher

Absolutely! Now, let’s remember—R-Y-O-T-W-A-R-I stands for 'Rights for Yielders, Obligations to Tenants, Welfare for Agricultural Regions, Individual Attention.' This will help you recall its focus.

Student 4
Student 4

What was the end result of these systems? Did they succeed?

Teacher
Teacher

Good question! Many parts of these systems were problematic and led to continued hardships for peasants. Let’s analyze how these systems set the stage for future conflicts in rural areas.

Challenges Faced by the New Systems

Unlock Audio Lesson

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Lesson

Teacher
Teacher

We’ve covered how the new systems functioned. What challenges do you think arose in these systems of revenue collection?

Student 2
Student 2

Maybe the demands were too high for the growers?

Teacher
Teacher

Yes! High revenue demands left many peasants locked in cycles of debt. Why might this be a problem for the Company's revenue in the long term?

Student 3
Student 3

If peasants are struggling, they won't be able to pay taxes.

Teacher
Teacher

Exactly! This created instability in the agricultural production which affected the overall economy. It also sowed the seeds for unrest among the peasants. Let’s summarize our main learnings today. What can we take away regarding the significance of these new systems?

Student 1
Student 1

They aimed to improve revenue but often created more hardships.

Teacher
Teacher

Spot on! Well done, everyone!

Introduction & Overview

Read a summary of the section's main ideas. Choose from Basic, Medium, or Detailed.

Quick Overview

The section discusses the changes introduced in the revenue system by the East India Company in the early 19th century, focusing on the mahalwari and ryotwari systems.

Standard

The section highlights the difficulties faced under the Permanent Settlement of 1793 and the subsequent introduction of the mahalwari and ryotwari systems in the early 1820s. It explains how these systems aimed to improve revenue collection and stabilize agricultural practices, though they also had their own set of challenges.

Detailed

Detailed Summary

In the early 19th century, the East India Company officials realized that the Permanent Settlement system established in 1793 was not effective. Land revenues were fixed permanently, which became unsustainable as the Company needed more funds for administration and trade. In response to this crisis, new systems of revenue collection were devised.

The Mahalwari Settlement

Under the mahalwari system implemented in the North Western Provinces in 1822, Holt Mackenzie emphasized the importance of villages as social structures. This system involved:
- Periodic revenue assessment: Revenue demands were reassessed periodically rather than fixed permanently.
- Village headman’s role: Revenue collection was assigned to the village headman instead of zamindars, fostering a direct relationship with the cultivators (ryots).

The Ryotwari System

Simultaneously, the ryotwari system emerged in southern India under Thomas Munro. Key features included:
- Direct engagement with ryots: The focus was on individual cultivators, as there were few traditional zamindars in the southern regions.
- Land surveys: Fields were surveyed to assess land and implement fair revenue collection.

Despite these improvements, both systems faced significant challenges such as high revenue demands, leading to difficulties for peasants. The longing for change led to increased tensions and eventual resistance among the agricultural community, highlighting the systemic adversities under British rule.

Youtube Videos

Ruling the Countryside Class 8 History | NCERT | CBSE | Class 8 History Chapter 3
Ruling the Countryside Class 8 History | NCERT | CBSE | Class 8 History Chapter 3
Ruling the Countryside - Full Chapter Explanation Solutions | Class 8 History Chapter 3
Ruling the Countryside - Full Chapter Explanation Solutions | Class 8 History Chapter 3
The Problems in Permanent Settlement - Ruling the Countryside | Class 8 History
The Problems in Permanent Settlement - Ruling the Countryside | Class 8 History
The Munro System - Ruling the Countryside | Class 8 History
The Munro System - Ruling the Countryside | Class 8 History
Ruling The Countryside Class 8 ( Full Animation ) | Class 8 History Chapter 3
Ruling The Countryside Class 8 ( Full Animation ) | Class 8 History Chapter 3
Ruling the Countryside - Rapid Revision in 20 Minutes🔥|| Social Studies, Class 8th 📚
Ruling the Countryside - Rapid Revision in 20 Minutes🔥|| Social Studies, Class 8th 📚
Class 8 History Chapter 3 - Ruling the Countryside | Class 8 history | Ruling the Countryside
Class 8 History Chapter 3 - Ruling the Countryside | Class 8 history | Ruling the Countryside
Ruling the Country side | Class 8 History Chapter 3 Part 1 | CHAMPS 2024 | BYJU'S
Ruling the Country side | Class 8 History Chapter 3 Part 1 | CHAMPS 2024 | BYJU'S
class 8 social science history chapter 3 ruling the country side #notes
class 8 social science history chapter 3 ruling the country side #notes

Audio Book

Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.

Introduction to the Need for Change

Unlock Audio Book

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Book

By the early nineteenth century, many of the Company officials were convinced that the system of revenue had to be changed again. How could revenues be fixed permanently at a time when the Company needed more money to meet its expenses of administration and trade?

Detailed Explanation

By the beginning of the 1800s, officials of the East India Company felt that the existing revenue system was outdated. The Company had previously fixed revenues permanently, but times had changed. Due to rising administrative costs and the need for more capital to support trade, officials questioned how they could continue to rely on a system that did not allow for flexibility in revenue collection. Essentially, they faced a dilemma: how to adjust the revenue system to better suit their growing financial needs while also addressing local realities.

Examples & Analogies

Think of a subscription service that locks you into a yearly fee. If your financial situation changes and you need more features (like adding family members), the rigid pricing becomes a problem. Companies often have to adapt their pricing strategies to accommodate their changing costs and customer needs, which is similar to what the Company faced.

Holt Mackenzie's Intervention

Unlock Audio Book

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Book

In the North Western Provinces of the Bengal Presidency (most of this area is now in Uttar Pradesh), an Englishman called Holt Mackenzie devised the new system which came into effect in 1822. He felt that the village was an important social institution in north Indian society and needed to be preserved.

Detailed Explanation

Holt Mackenzie, an English administrator, introduced a fresh approach to revenue collection in 1822. He recognized that villages were central to the social structure in North India, meaning the traditional community dynamics had to be respected. Instead of focusing on larger landlords, Mackenzie directed his collectors to engage with individual villages to evaluate land and its use. The goal was to establish a revenue system that would be adaptable over time, rather than one set in stone.

Examples & Analogies

Imagine a farmer who grows vegetables on different plots of land. If the market changes and she has to adapt her crops, her ability to do so should depend on the specific conditions of each plot. Similarly, a responsive revenue system allows each village to adjust based on its unique circumstances.

Mahalwari Settlement

Unlock Audio Book

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Book

Under his directions, collectors went from village to village, inspecting the land, measuring the fields, and recording the customs and rights of different groups. The estimated revenue of each plot within a village was added up to calculate the revenue that each village (mahal) had to pay. This demand was to be revised periodically, not permanently fixed.

Detailed Explanation

Mackenzie’s mahalwari settlement fundamentally changed how revenue was assessed. Collectors visited villages to meticulously measure land and understand local customs. Unlike the permanent revenue system, which imposed a fixed tax, the new system allowed for periodic reviews and adjustments to the revenue demand, making it more flexible and reflective of each village's current economic realities.

Examples & Analogies

Think of renting an apartment where your landlord adjusts the rent based on improvements you make to your living space or changes in the local market. This kind of adaptability can make the financial arrangement more fair and functional for both parties.

The Munro System in the South

Unlock Audio Book

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Book

In the British territories in the South, there was a similar move away from the idea of Permanent Settlement. The new system that was devised came to be known as the ryotwar (or ryotwari). It was tried on a small scale by Captain Alexander Read in some of the areas that were taken over by the Company after the wars with Tipu Sultan.

Detailed Explanation

In Southern India, a different approach was taken to ensure the revenue system was beneficial. The ryotwari system, developed primarily by Thomas Munro, focused on direct relationships with individual cultivators known as ryots. Here, the government assessed land directly based on its productivity, instead of dealing with intermediate landlords. This approach was seen as beneficial because the British believed it would ensure a better collection of revenue while empowering farmers.

Examples & Analogies

Imagine a bakery buying flour directly from farmers instead of going through a distributor. By cutting out the middleman, the bakery may pay a fair price and the farmers receive compensation closer to their actual output, which is similar to how the ryotwari system attempted to function.

Challenges of the New Systems

Unlock Audio Book

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Book

Within a few years after the new systems were imposed, it was clear that all was not well with them. Driven by the desire to increase the income from land, revenue officials fixed too high a revenue demand. Peasants were unable to pay, ryots fled the countryside, and villages became deserted in many regions.

Detailed Explanation

Although the new systems were designed to be more flexible, they had unintended negative consequences. Revenue officials, eager to increase state income, set revenue demands too high for many peasants to meet. Faced with insurmountable debts and pressures, many tenant farmers abandoned their lands, leading to empty villages and economic decline, which undermined the very purpose of the new systems.

Examples & Analogies

Consider a company that increases its sales targets too drastically. Employees, feeling the pressure, may leave their jobs instead of meeting unachievable goals. Similarly, when the revenue expectations became too high, the farmers opted to leave rather than face financial ruin.

Crops for Europe

Unlock Audio Book

Signup and Enroll to the course for listening the Audio Book

The British also realised that the countryside could not only yield revenue, it could also grow the crops that Europe required. By the late eighteenth century, the Company was trying its best to expand the cultivation of opium and indigo.

Detailed Explanation

As the British established their control over Indian territories, they identified agricultural production as a potential income source. The Company began promoting the cultivation of specific cash crops like opium and indigo, which were in demand in Europe. This shift not only aimed to increase revenue through taxation but also aligned Indian agricultural production with the needs of European markets.

Examples & Analogies

Think of how a supermarket decides to stock more of a popular product based on demand. If a certain snack is flying off the shelves, the store focuses on getting more of it to satisfy customers while increasing profits. The British were doing something similar by focusing on crops that had high demand in Europe.

Definitions & Key Concepts

Learn essential terms and foundational ideas that form the basis of the topic.

Key Concepts

  • Mahalwari System: A flexible revenue assessment model focused on village-level governance.

  • Ryotwari System: Direct engagement with ryots to assure individual land rights and revenue collection.

  • Permanent Settlement: A fixed revenue system that led to economic challenges.

  • Zamindar: Designated tax collector under the Permanent Settlement.

  • Debt Cycle: The financial struggles faced by peasants resulting from high taxes.

Examples & Real-Life Applications

See how the concepts apply in real-world scenarios to understand their practical implications.

Examples

  • Holt Mackenzie implemented the mahalwari system to reassess tax demands based on agrarian realities in North Western Provinces, fostering village participation.

  • The ryotwari system, introduced by Thomas Munro, allowed direct agreements between individual farmers and the government, intended to stabilize agriculture.

Memory Aids

Use mnemonics, acronyms, or visual cues to help remember key information more easily.

🎵 Rhymes Time

  • In fields of ryots, we must unite, To pay our dues and do what's right.

📖 Fascinating Stories

  • Once upon a time in precolonial India, zamindars were powerful but taxing the poor made many farmers sad. Then came the mahalwari to help, but, was it enough with its high demand?

🧠 Other Memory Gems

  • R-Y-O-T-W-A-R-I: Rights yield, Obligations to tenants, Welfare accounts, Individual focus.

🎯 Super Acronyms

M-A-H-A-L-W-A-R-I

  • Modern Assessment
  • Headman Authority
  • Local Welfare
  • Regular Inspection.

Flash Cards

Review key concepts with flashcards.

Glossary of Terms

Review the Definitions for terms.

  • Term: Mahalwari System

    Definition:

    A revenue system introduced by the East India Company that assessed village taxes periodically and empowered village headmen to collect them.

  • Term: Ryotwari System

    Definition:

    A revenue system focusing on individual cultivators (ryots) by enabling them to engage directly with revenue officials.

  • Term: Permanent Settlement

    Definition:

    A revenue system that fixed land revenue permanently and appointed zamindars as collectors.

  • Term: Zamindar

    Definition:

    Landowners responsible for collecting taxes from peasants under the Permanent Settlement.

  • Term: Ryot

    Definition:

    The agricultural laborer or tenant who cultivates the land.