3 - Government and NGO Involvement
Enroll to start learning
You’ve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
Impact of the 2001 Earthquake
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Today, we will discuss the devastating impact of the 2001 earthquake, which destroyed over 80% of houses in the affected area. Can anyone tell me what happens to a community when such a large number of homes are lost?
The community would face displacement and loss of resources.
Exactly! People lose their homes and their sense of belonging. Now, how do you think the rebuilding of homes can affect community dynamics?
It can help rebuild the community, but if the new homes are not accepted, it could create more problems.
Great point! The new layouts did not consider the preferences of many residents, leading to many unoccupied houses.
Role of NGOs and Government
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Let’s discuss the roles of NGOs and the government in these reconstruction efforts. What was a major critique of how NGOs operated during the rebuilding process?
They didn’t involve the villagers in decision-making.
Correct! The NGOs made unilateral decisions, often without input from the community, leading to resistance and failure of the projects.
If people weren't included, why do you think that was a problem?
That's an excellent question! Without local participation, the homes built were often viewed as unsuitable or unwanted by the residents, escalating mistrust towards NGOs.
Consequences of Poor Planning
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now, let’s focus on the consequences of poor planning and lack of local resource utilization. What can you tell me about the result of using external materials for construction?
It probably led to higher costs and houses that didn’t fit the community's needs.
Right! It increased costs significantly, and many homes remained unoccupied because they failed to match the community’s preferences not only financially but also culturally.
What happened to the health centers if people were not using them?
An important observation! The health centers went underutilized, reflecting broader issues with community engagement in reconstruction.
Community NGOs Partnership Approach
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Let’s shift our focus to a different scenario. Can anyone share how the community NGO partnership approach differs from what we discussed earlier?
It would involve the community more in the decision-making process.
Precisely! In Ludiya village, which was 100 kilometers north of Bhuj, the partnership ensured locals were involved in rebuilding efforts, enhancing the project’s effectiveness.
What roles do you think animal husbandry and local crafts played in rebuilding that community?
These occupations likely helped maintain the community's structure and identity, creating a stronger foundation for development post-earthquake.
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
The section examines the aftermath of the 2001 earthquake, highlighting issues with reconstruction efforts led by NGOs without local involvement, ultimately resulting in unoccupied homes, lack of utilization of local resources, and dissatisfaction among the affected communities.
Detailed
In this section, we delve into the impacts of the 2001 earthquake, which caused massive destruction, with over 80% of homes severely damaged. The reconstruction efforts showcased a stark disconnect between the planned layouts designed by NGOs and the preferences of local residents. Many people chose not to relocate due to abandonment of the new layouts and a lack of formal land rights. Despite the availability of local resources, the design process was top-down, leading to high costs and social rejection of the new housing. Key institutions, such as health centers and schools, faced underutilization while certain groups, notably wealthier residents, built their own structures rather than engaging with the reconstruction projects. The absence of local participation severely diminished the effectiveness of aid, fostering distrust towards NGOs and heightening community vulnerabilities.
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
Damage and Reconstruction Challenges
Chapter 1 of 10
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
More than 80% of the houses were totally damaged by the 2001 earthquake. The reconstructions, so this was the existing before the earthquake that was the layout and this was the newly located village layout. You can see here that these yellow colours are abandoned places and some people who do not have any land rights in this area, no land rights, they do not have any formal land rights and many people they did not relocate it.
Detailed Explanation
In 2001, a devastating earthquake damaged over 80% of houses. The reconstruction involved creating a new village layout that differed from the original, resulting in many abandoned areas as people with no formal land rights could not relocate. Many residents chose to stay where they were instead of moving to the new layout.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine if a town was hit by a flood and rebuilt with a completely different plan that wasn't familiar to the residents. Many people might hesitate to move into the new layout, especially if they felt they had no secure place to stay.
Occupancy Issues
Chapter 2 of 10
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
This is the number of occupancy in the new, you can see these new constructed houses lying empty, the cost of dwelling units was 1 lakh 20,000 Indian rupees according to that time comparatively much higher. So, most of the houses are vacant, only yellow part you can occupied and you can see here that many people did not actually relocate it to the newly constructed house because it is a totally different layout.
Detailed Explanation
Many of the newly constructed houses remained empty because they were expensive at 1 lakh 20,000 Indian rupees. The unfamiliar layout discouraged people from relocating, and the majority chose not to occupy these new homes.
Examples & Analogies
Think of it like trying to sell a new smartphone that looks and works completely differently than the one everyone is used to. Even if it's better, people might stick with their old devices out of comfort and familiarity.
Health and Education Facilities
Chapter 3 of 10
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
They have health center but, people are not using that. Ayurvedic health centre also, this is not used by the people, the schools are there is primarily; primary school, this is working well, people are using it, people are sending their kids there, panchayat office is rebuilt, electricity installed, telecommunication system was installed.
Detailed Explanation
Although the area had rebuilt health and educational facilities, there was low utilization of the health centers, including an Ayurvedic center. In contrast, the primary school was functioning well as parents sent their children there. Other infrastructure like the panchayat office and basic utilities were also restored.
Examples & Analogies
It’s like building a brand new gym with the best equipment but if the community doesn’t feel comfortable using it, they might prefer to stick to their existing workout routines or spaces, while the library (the school) becomes a popular spot because it provides value that people appreciate.
Reconstruction Inequities
Chapter 4 of 10
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Constructions; those who are rich they did not relocate better off and they built their own house in the damaged side, some people who did not have land tenure rights, constructed temporary houses or got temporary houses and remaining there, they were not included into the reconstruction projects and the newly constructed projects remain unoccupied.
Detailed Explanation
Wealthier individuals often chose not to relocate and instead built new houses on the damaged sites. Meanwhile, those without land rights had limited options and often lived in temporary housing. This disparity left many new constructions unoccupied as the marginalized groups did not benefit from reconstruction efforts.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a situation where during a makeover of a neighborhood, the wealthy families get to choose the best spots to build their new homes, while the poorer families are given only temporary shelters that don’t address their long-term needs. As a result, the revitalized neighborhood remains partially empty.
Community Participation Lacking
Chapter 5 of 10
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Because, these people preferred to live together, they did not like this new iron-grid pattern of layout, it was done by the Hindustan Benevolent. There was no training program, allocation of financial assistance given to the NGO directly and decision makings, villages were not involved into the decision-making process.
Detailed Explanation
The community preferred to live in close-knit neighborhoods and rejected the planned layout imposed by NGOs. Additionally, there was a lack of training programs or financial assistance directed towards local involvement in these decisions, which created a disconnect between the NGOs and the villagers.
Examples & Analogies
This is like a city council deciding to change the layout of a beloved neighborhood without asking the residents for input. The community would likely feel alienated and unhappy with the new changes since they were not part of the planning process.
Material and Labor Concerns
Chapter 6 of 10
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Building materials; all building materials for these reconstructions were locally available building materials, contractor bought the building materials from outside, entirely designed by the NGO without any involvement of the people and it took 1 year 2 months to finish this project.
Detailed Explanation
Although local materials were available, the contractors sourced materials from outside sources and completed the project based on designs set by the NGO, without local community input. This process took over a year to finish.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a restaurant that decides to serve a dish using local ingredients, but the chef isn’t from the region and ignores regional cooking methods and preferences. The end result might not resonate with the locals, despite the good ingredients.
Consequences of Poor Planning
Chapter 7 of 10
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, what do we see here that no utilisations of local resources designed by the NGO, no training program, NGO decide every aspect; very weak organizational setup and absence of ownership right, people refuse this one and absence of monitoring also.
Detailed Explanation
The reconstruction suffered from a lack of community resource utilization and involvement. Decisions were solely made by the NGOs, leading to a weak organizational structure. Additionally, with no ownership rights established for the residents, acceptance of the new structures faltered.
Examples & Analogies
It's like a group of students getting a project directly handed to them by teachers without any input. Because they had no say, they might not be as invested or care about the outcome.
Community-NGO Dynamics
Chapter 8 of 10
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
In community NGO partnership approach, we have Ludiya village, there is 100 kilometer north from Bhuj, area is around 5 square kilometer, total population is 1800 mainly by Harijans and Muslims population comprised by literacy rate was 35%.
Detailed Explanation
Shifting to a different scenario in Ludiya village, which is 100 kilometers north of Bhuj, we see a community of about 1,800 people comprising primarily Harijans and Muslims, with a literacy rate of 35%. This indicates a diverse yet economically disadvantaged population that could benefit from targeted support.
Examples & Analogies
Think of a small community of schools where students from different backgrounds come together. The school creates programs that cater to the varied needs of its students, enhancing education through inclusivity and involvement.
Occupational Overview
Chapter 9 of 10
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
You can see that most of the people are involved in cattle rearing and wood cravings, so 50% of them are in cattle rearing and animal husbandry and some are also involved in agriculture around 20% of populations.
Detailed Explanation
In this village, about 50% of the population engages in cattle rearing and animal husbandry, while around 20% are involved in agriculture. This indicates an economy largely dependent on traditional practices.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine in a rural area where the majority of families depend on farming and animal care for their livelihoods. The economic health of the community would directly link to how well these families perform in their agricultural and animal husbandry practices.
Social Disparities
Chapter 10 of 10
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
And distribution of community also, you can see that there is a segregations that Harijans are there and here are the Muslims populations, these two communities and there is a poor community basically around Indian rupees 2500 to 5000, this shared the entire pie almost 90%.
Detailed Explanation
In Ludiya, there is a visible social division between Harijans and Muslims. The economic situation is precarious, with a significant portion of the population living on only 2,500 to 5,000 Indian rupees, indicating that 90% of the community is significantly struggling financially.
Examples & Analogies
Picture a small town where only a few people have good jobs while the majority are living paycheck to paycheck. The economic divide can create tension and disparity in opportunities within the community.
Key Concepts
-
Community Resilience: The ability of a community to recover and adapt after a disaster.
-
Top-Down Planning: An approach where decisions are made by higher authorities without community input.
-
NGO Accountability: The responsibility of NGOs to the communities they serve and the effectiveness of their interventions.
Examples & Applications
An example of poor planning is the construction of new houses that remain empty due to community rejection.
In Ludiya, a village in Gujarat, the partnership with NGOs involved locals which improved the success of rebuilding after the earthquake.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
In a quake, homes did break, many families did forsake; leaders planned with no demand, their designs failed to withstand.
Stories
After the earthquake, a village was torn apart. The people, worried and displaced, found that the new houses felt foreign and uninviting. They missed their old community blend. Thus, the new layout was rejected, and they longed to rebuild together, with a voice heard once again.
Memory Tools
NGO: No Good Organizing without locals! Remember that engagement is key in rebuilding.
Acronyms
REBUILD
Respect people's voices
Evaluate needs
Build together
Utilize local resources
Include community
Design for acceptance.
Flash Cards
Glossary
- Earthquake
A sudden and violent shaking of the ground, often leading to significant destruction.
- Reconstruction
The process of rebuilding structures and restoring communities after a disaster.
- NGO (NonGovernmental Organization)
A non-profit organization that operates independently of government, often focused on humanitarian or social issues.
- Land Tenure Rights
Legal rights related to ownership and use of land.
- Community Participation
The involvement of local individuals in decisions affecting their lives and communities.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.