5.1.1 - Developing Focused and Debatable Questions
Enroll to start learning
Youβve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
From Topic to Question
π Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Today, weβre going to learn how to transform a broad topic into a focused research question. For example, if your topic is 'Climate Change', how do we make it specific?
Maybe we can look at its impact on a specific area, like coastal communities?
Exactly! Now, instead of just 'Climate Change', we could say, 'What is the impact of climate change on coastal communities?' Thatβs a great start! But let's make it even more detailed.
Could we explore economic aspects, like fishing practices, in a specific region?
Yes! How about we refine it further to something like 'To what extent has climate change, causing rising sea levels, affected traditional fishing practices in the Sundarbans region in Bangladesh?' Thatβs a focused and specific research question.
That sounds much better! It feels like we have a clear path to research now.
Great observation! Remember, a specific question guides your investigation.
Characteristics of a Good Research Question
π Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now, letβs dive into the characteristics of a good research question. A strong question should be focused, researchable, debatable, relevant, and clear. Can anyone provide an example of what being too broad might look like?
What about 'How does social media affect people?' That seems really broad!
Right! Thatβs a great point. Instead, we could focus it down to 'How does the use of Instagram by teenagers in urban areas influence their perceptions of body image?' See how much more specific that is?
It allows for more targeted research!
Perfect! Also, a good question must be researchable. Who can give an example of a question that's not researchable?
What is the best type of music? That seems way too subjective.
Exactly, great job! When crafting research questions, aim for those that can lead to measurable evidence.
Using Question Stems
π Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Next, letβs look at question stems! These are phrases that can help frame your questions. For example, starting with 'To what extent...' encourages analysis. Can anyone suggest a question using that stem?
To what extent does social inequality affect educational opportunities in urban settings?
Great job! Thatβs a question that can lead to substantial investigation! What about 'How does... impact...?'
How does urban development impact local wildlife? It could open up many areas of exploration.
Exactly! Using stems like these helps structure your inquiry. Remember to always consider the implications of your questions as well.
Refining Your Question
π Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Finally, letβs talk about refining your research questions. This is an iterative process where you review and adjust your questions. Can anyone share how they might refine their questions?
If my question feels too simple, I might think about adding complexity. Like, instead of just asking about the effects, maybe I could include comparisons!
Great idea! Or if it's too complex, you might want to break it down into smaller parts. Always ask yourself if you can answer it with available resources.
Or make sure itβs focused enough to avoid confusion?
Exactly! Refining is crucial to ensuring your question truly captures what you want to investigate. Let's summarize what weβve learned today.
Summarizing Key Concepts
π Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Alright, class! Letβs quickly recap what weβve learned today about developing focused and debatable questions.
We went from broad topics to specific questions!
And we learned the characteristics of good research questions - focused, researchable, debatable, and more!
Exactly! And we also explored question stems. Remember, using phrases like 'To what extent...' can significantly help frame your questions!
And we talked about the importance of refining our questions for precision.
Well done, everyone! Keep these strategies in mind as you further develop your research inquiries.
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
In this section, students learn how to transition from broad topics to precise research questions that are narrow, researchable, debatable, relevant, and clear. The section covers characteristics of good research questions, the use of question stems, and the iterative process of refining questions to ensure they adequately reflect the researcher's inquiry.
Detailed
In the realm of research, particularly within the Individuals and Societies framework, defining a strong research question is essential. A good research question should not only focus on a specific area of inquiry but also be crafted in a way that it invites analysis and exploration. The transition from a broad topic to a focused research question involves several key steps:
- From Topic to Question: Start with a broad topic, narrow it down to a specific aspect, and finally formulate a precise research question. For instance, while 'Climate Change' is a broad topic, the question 'To what extent has rising sea levels, attributed to climate change, impacted the traditional fishing practices and economic stability of the Sundarbans region in Bangladesh over the past two decades?' is specific and focused.
- Characteristics of a Good Research Question: A well-crafted question should be focused, researchable, debatable, relevant, and clear. This requires avoiding overly broad inquiries, ensuring the availability of information, and inviting diverse perspectives for analysis.
- Using Question Stems: Engaging with specific phrases can help structure a research question, such as 'To what extent...?', 'How does...?', and 'What are the implications of...?'.
- Refining Your Question: The refinement of questions is an iterative process, where students should continuously assess their questions for clarity, complexity, and relevance.
This section serves as a foundational component for students to engage critically in research and inquiry, equipping them with the skills necessary for their MYP projects.
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
From Topic to Question
Chapter 1 of 4
π Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
A strong research question is not merely a topic; it's a specific, inquiry-driven query that can be explored through evidence and analysis, leading to a thoughtful conclusion.
- Topic: Broad area of interest (e.g., "Climate Change").
- Narrowed Topic: A specific aspect of the broad topic (e.g., "Impact of climate change on coastal communities").
- Research Question: A focused, open-ended question that guides your investigation (e.g., "To what extent has rising sea levels, attributed to climate change, impacted the traditional fishing practices and economic stability of the Sundarbans region in Bangladesh over the past two decades?").
Detailed Explanation
In research, the first step is to define a topic, which is a general area you are interested in. However, a topic alone is not enough because it can be too broad. To create a more focused area, you first narrow it down to a narrowed topic. For instance, from the broad topic of "climate change," you can narrow it to the "impact of climate change on coastal communities". The final step is to formulate a research question, which is a clear and specific inquiry that you can investigate. For example, you could ask, 'To what extent has rising sea levels affected fishing practices in Bangladesh?' This question is researchable and sets a clear direction for your investigation.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine you are interested in cooking, and you start by thinking about food. That's your broad topic. If you then think about how different spices affect Vietnamese cuisine, thatβs your narrowed topic. Finally, if you ask, 'How does the use of lemongrass influence the flavor of traditional pho?' thatβs your research question. Itβs specific and can be investigated through cooking and tasting.
Characteristics of a Good Research Question
Chapter 2 of 4
π Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
- Focused: Specific and manageable. Avoid vague questions.
- Too broad: "How does social media affect people?"
- Focused: "How does the use of Instagram by teenagers in urban areas of Delhi influence their perceptions of body image?"
- Researchable: Sufficient information should be available.
- Not researchable: "What is the best type of music?"
- Researchable: "How do different genres of music impact the mood and concentration levels of Grade 9 students during study sessions?"
- Debatable/Analyzable: Allows for multiple perspectives.
- Not debatable: "Is poverty a problem?"
- Debatable: "To what extent do government welfare programs effectively reduce intergenerational poverty in urban Indian communities?"
- Relevant: Should address a significant issue.
- Clear and Unambiguous: Use precise language without jargon.
Detailed Explanation
A good research question should have several key characteristics. First, it should be focused, meaning itβs specific and narrow. Asking broadly about social media is not helpful, but asking about Instagram's effect on teenagersβ body image is specific. Second, your question must be researchable; you need to find relevant information to answer it. A subjective question, like 'What is the best type of music?' doesn't work because itβs too personal. Third, it should be debatable; you want to ask questions that can have multiple viewpoints. Instead of simply asking if poverty is a problem, asking how effective welfare programs are in reducing it encourages discussion. The question should also be relevant to current societal issues and expressed in clear, straightforward language.
Examples & Analogies
Think of crafting a research question like ordering a pizza. If you ask for 'food,' that's way too broad. If you ask for 'pepperoni pizza,' that's better; itβs specific. If you also want to know how well it fits the theme of a party, that's focused and debatable. Each characteristic helps ensure you get exactly what you need.
Using Question Stems
Chapter 3 of 4
π Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Using Question Stems: Starting with certain words can help formulate better questions:
- "To what extent...?" (Invites analysis of degree or impact)
- "How does... impact/influence...?" (Focuses on cause and effect)
- "What are the implications of... for...?" (Explores consequences)
- "How effectively...?" (Evaluates success)
- "In what ways...?" (Explores different aspects)
- "What are the perspectives on...?" (Focuses on different viewpoints)
Detailed Explanation
To create effective research questions, consider using specific phrases, known as question stems. These stem prompts guide the type of question youβll ask. For example, if you want to analyze how social media influences opinions, starting with 'How does social media influence...' invites an exploration of the effects. Similarly, if you want to look at different viewpoints on an issue, starting with 'What are the perspectives on...' helps frame your question to cover diverse opinions. Each stem helps ensure your question is engaging and open to discussion.
Examples & Analogies
Think of question stems like different tools in a toolbox. Just as a hammer is great for nails, a wrench is better for tightening bolts. Likewise, some stems are better for different types of questions. If you want to dig deep into a topic, use βhowβ or βwhat,β much like choosing the right tool for the job!
Refining Your Question
Chapter 4 of 4
π Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Refining Your Question: It's an iterative process. Start broad, then narrow it down. Ask yourself:
- Can I answer this with the resources available?
- Is it too simple? Can I get a more complex answer?
- Is it too complex? Can I break it down?
- Does it truly reflect what I want to investigate?
- Does it lead to analysis, or just description?
Activity Idea: Provide students with a broad topic (e.g., "Democracy," "Global Warming," "Cultural Identity"). Have them brainstorm three progressively more focused and debatable research questions related to the topic, explaining why each improved from the last.
Detailed Explanation
Refining your research question is crucial and typically involves several steps. Start with a broad interest, and as you think about it, narrow it down to something more specific. Ask yourself if the question can be answered with the resources you have. Is it too simple, or does it open avenues for deeper analysis? Sometimes a question can be too complex, and you need to break it down into smaller parts. Make sure the final version reflects what you truly want to study and encourages analytical thinking rather than just descriptive answers. This iterative process helps create a strong, researchable question.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine you are planning to run a marathon. At first, your goal might be to get fit (broad goal)βthatβs too vague. Then, you narrow it to running twice a week (narrowed goal)βstill not enough information about how to succeed. Finally, you formulate a detailed goal such as: 'What is the most effective training schedule to get a beginner ready for a marathon in 3 months?' This detailed goal reflects your commitment to your personal fitness journey.
Key Concepts
-
Transitioning from a topic to a focused research question involves narrowing down the scope.
-
A good research question should be focused, researchable, debatable, clear, and relevant.
-
Using specific question stems aids in crafting effective research questions.
-
Refining research questions is an iterative process that ensures clarity and purpose.
Examples & Applications
Starting with the broad topic 'Climate Change', narrowing it down to 'The impact of climate change on coastal communities' and finally to 'To what extent has climate change impacted traditional fishing practices in the Sundarbans region?'
Instead of asking 'How does social media affect people?', framing it as 'How does the use of Instagram by teenagers in urban areas of Delhi influence their perceptions of body image?' provides specificity.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
To find a question that's so bright, make it focused, clear, and right.
Stories
Imagine a researcher, lost in a field of ideas like a kid in a candy store. By asking, 'What's the tastiest candy?' they zoom in on the best sweet, rather than getting overwhelmed by the choices around them.
Memory Tools
Remember: 'FRED C.' - Focused, Researchable, Easily understood, Debatable, Clear.
Acronyms
SIMPLE - Specific, Inquiry-driven, Manageable, Provocative, Logical, Engaging.
Flash Cards
Glossary
- Research Question
A specific, inquiry-driven question that guides an investigation.
- Debatable Question
A question that allows for multiple perspectives or interpretations, inviting analysis rather than simple 'yes' or 'no' answers.
- Focused Question
A question that is specific and narrow enough to be manageable within the given time and resources.
- Researchable Question
A question that can be answered through available evidence and analysis, rather than purely subjective opinions.
- Question Stems
Phrases used to formulate research questions, such as 'To what extent...' or 'How does...'.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.