4.1 - Cycle Time Analysis
Enroll to start learning
You’ve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
Introduction to Back-Track Loading
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Today, we're going to discuss the back-track loading method. Can anyone explain how it works?
Is it when the pusher has to return after loading a scraper?
Exactly, Student_1! The pusher detaches after loading one scraper and has to backtrack to load the next one. This method is preferred in many cases because it maintains a consistent cutting direction.
But why is it considered the slowest method?
Great question, Student_2! It’s because of the additional time the pusher spends returning, which increases the cycle time.
So if it takes longer, why do people still use it?
It’s often about the preference for maintaining efficiency in cutting direction. Remember, it’s the "back-track" method due to the backtracking it requires!
In summary, while back-track loading is slow, its popularity is due to its directional consistency.
Exploring Chain Loading
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Next, let's explore chain loading. Can anyone summarize how it differs from back-track loading?
I think the pusher stays put after loading the first scraper, and the next scraper just comes to it!
Good job, Student_1! This method significantly reduces return time by eliminating the backtrack phase.
Why is chain loading specifically suited for long cuts like roads?
It's because that setup allows for quicker loading cycles, essential for continuous work in long-narrow environments. Picture it—long roads, continuous work, less waiting time!
To sum up, chain loading improves efficiency by minimizing the return time typically associated with backtracking.
Understanding Shuttle Loading
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Finally, let's discuss shuttle loading. What do we know about it?
I think it's when you have two fill areas, right? The pusher can go in both directions.
That's correct, Student_2! It allows the pusher to detach and immediately push another scraper in the opposite direction.
Does this method also reduce cycle time?
Yes! Like chain loading, it enhances productivity by reducing waiting time. But remember, it's not widely used compared to back-track and chain loading.
In short, shuttle loading is all about optimizing time when working in areas with fill in multiple directions.
Cycle Time Calculation
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now, how do we determine the cycle time for the pusher?
You mentioned a formula earlier, right? Can we use loading time in that?
Exactly, Student_4! The formula is Tp = 1.4Lt + 0.25, where Tp is the pusher cycle time, and Lt is the scraper load time.
Why do we need to balance the number of scrapers and pushers?
Balancing the machines minimizes waiting time for both the scraper and the pusher, ensuring they operate at maximum capacity!
In summary, understanding how to calculate pusher cycle time and balancing machines are critical for optimizing operation efficiency.
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
This section explores different loading methods for scrapers, namely back-track loading, chain loading, and shuttle loading. It emphasizes that while back-track loading is commonly adopted, it is the slowest due to return time. Conversely, chain and shuttle loading methods improve efficiency in long operations and can reduce overall cycle time.
Detailed
Cycle Time Analysis
In this section, we delve into the analysis of cycle time concerning loading methods used in construction equipment, particularly scrapers and pushers. The methods discussed include:
1. Back-Track Loading Method
- Overview: This method involves the pusher detaching and returning to pick up the next scraper after one is loaded.
- Significance: Although widely used for its preference for maintaining a consistent cutting direction, it is deemed the slowest method due to the time required to backtrack.
2. Chain Loading Method
- Overview: A more efficient method preferably employed for long cuts, such as roads, where once the first scraper is loaded, the pusher detaches and stays stationary to push the next scraper coming up.
- Significance: This reduces return time significantly compared to the back-track method, thereby enhancing efficiency and minimizing cycle time.
3. Shuttle Loading Method
- Overview: This method is utilized when there are fill areas in both directions. The pusher moves between scrapers that are operating in opposite directions.
- Significance: Like chain loading, it offers reduced return time and thereby lowers cycle time but is less common.
The section concludes with a mathematical formula to estimate cycle time based on scraper load time, necessary for balancing the interdependent operation of scrapers and pushers, ensuring optimal productivity by minimizing waiting times.
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
Back-Track Loading Method
Chapter 1 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, once the loading of scraper 1 is completed, the pusher will back-track return back and spot the next a scraper, scraper 2 and start pushing it in the same direction. So, that is what is a back-track loading. So, first it is pushing the scraper 1, as a scraper 1 is completely loaded it will start moving on its own. Once the scraper 1 is loaded, your pusher will get detached and return that is backtracking, backtrack and it has to travel some distance and spot the next scraper 2. And then start pushing again in the same direction, it starts moving again in the same direction. So, that is what is your back-track loading method. So, one limitation of this back-track loading method is it needs additional time for returning back backtracking. So, that is why we call this as a slowest method. So, this is the slowest of all the methods which we are going to discuss now.
Detailed Explanation
The back-track loading method involves a series of steps where a pusher loads a scraper, and then, after unloading, returns to fetch the next scraper. This method is considered slow because the pusher needs to make a return journey which adds more time to the overall cycle. In essence, the loading process starts with the pusher engaging the first scraper (scraper 1), which, once fully loaded, moves on its own. The pusher then detaches and backtracks to find scraper 2, introducing a time delay associated with the additional travel needed for backtracking.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a waiter serving food at a restaurant. After serving a table, the waiter has to return to the kitchen for another order before serving the next table. Just like the waiter, the pusher has to travel back to pick up the next scraper and this traveling time makes the process slower.
Limitations of Back-Track Method
Chapter 2 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, here you can see that the return time is more, return time is more because of the backtracking. So, everything the actual value will depend upon your project site. So, we cannot tell the exact value but basically your back-track method takes longer time because the pusher has to return back, it has to back-track and spot the next scraper and then start pushing it again in the same direction. But this is more commonly adopted by everyone because the people prefer the cutting in the same direction.
Detailed Explanation
The effectiveness of the back-track method is influenced by the physical layout of the project site; longer distances between scrapers and varying terrain can increase backtrack time significantly. Therefore, while this method is slower, it is often preferred due to its simplicity and because it allows for continuous cutting in a uniform direction, reducing complications during the operation.
Examples & Analogies
Think about a train traveling on a circular track. If it has to take a detour to return to the start before picking up passengers at a new station, it is slower than if there were direct stops along the way. Operators choose this method for its straightforwardness, much like how the train operates continuously on the same track.
Chain Loading Method
Chapter 3 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, the next method which we are going to discuss is your chain loading method. So, this we commonly follow for long cuts, long narrow cuts like your roads, we can follow the chain loading method, say here your pusher is pushing the scraper 1, once a scraper 1 is completely loaded the scraper 1 is now in fully loaded condition. Now your pusher will get detached from the scraper 1 and the pusher start pushing the next scraper. But here is what happens the scraper 2 will come and wait near the pusher. Your pusher may not backtrack again; it may not return back again and spot the next scraper.
Detailed Explanation
In the chain loading method, the process is more efficient compared to back-track loading. Once scraper 1 is loaded, instead of the pusher traveling back to grab the next scraper, scraper 2 is already positioned near the pusher. This reduces the return time significantly, making the cycle time shorter. Thus, this method is particularly beneficial for long and narrow projects such as roads where scrapers can be lined up waiting for the pusher.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a production line in a factory where workers pass items from one to another. Instead of going back to pick up new items, the next worker in the line is already ready to receive and process the previous item. This keeps the line moving smoothly and efficiently, just like how chain loading minimizes waiting time.
Shuttle Loading Method
Chapter 4 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
The next one is shuttle loading, this is not commonly followed, but you can follow it when you have 2 fill areas. That means you have a fill area in this direction as well as you have fill area in this direction. If you have fill areas in both the direction, then you can follow the shuttle loading. So, what happens here is the pusher is pushing the scraper 1. The scraper 1 is now completely fully loaded, it is fully loaded. After that your pusher is getting detached from the scraper 1 and it starts pushing another scraper in the opposite direction.
Detailed Explanation
The shuttle loading method is advantageous when there are fill areas available in both directions. Once the pusher finishes loading scraper 1, instead of returning to one direction to pick up another scraper, it switches and pushes a scraper in the opposite direction. This method further reduces return time and consequently, the overall cycle time. However, its application is limited since it requires specific site conditions.
Examples & Analogies
Think about a swing that can go back and forth. If one side of the swing is full of kids waiting to go, the swing can just continue back and forth without stopping to return to the starting point. This efficiency showcases how shuttle loading maximizes operations in settings where multiple loading zones are available.
Comparative Cycle Times of Methods
Chapter 5 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, when you compare all these 3 methods, you can see that your back-track is the slowest method, the cycle time is relatively higher because it has to backtrack or return to support the next scraper but your chain and shuttle loading though they are not commonly followed so, but they are having the lesser cycle time and we know the reasons already.
Detailed Explanation
In summary, the back-track loading method is the slowest due to the necessary return journey, leading to greater cycle times compared to chain and shuttle loading methods. The latter two methods are more efficient as they reduce the return travel distance, ensuring that scrapers are continually loaded and unloaded with minimal downtime.
Examples & Analogies
Consider different delivery methods in a shipping company. A delivery truck that has to return to the warehouse for each drop-off will take longer than one that can deliver multiple items in a single round, similar to how chain and shuttle loading optimize the loading and unloading process.
Calculating Cycle Time
Chapter 6 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, to summarize back-track loading method is the slowest of all the methods because of the additional pusher travel time for backtracking on returning. But most commonly followed because people prefer cutting in the same direction. Chain loading, it is suited for long and a narrow cut, here the return time is reduced. Shuttle loading requests 2 separate fill areas in both direction. So, you can see scrapers moving in both directions, this is also having shorter cycle, but this is the one which is commonly followed.
Detailed Explanation
To determine the cycle time of the pusher, one can use a formula based on the loading time of the scraper. The relationship between the two is given as Tp = 1.4Lt + 0.25, where Tp is the cycle time of the pusher and Lt is the loading time. Understanding this relationship is crucial for planning and optimizing the loading processes on construction sites.
Examples & Analogies
Think about calculating the time it takes to bake cookies. If you know how long it takes to bake one batch (loading time), you can estimate how many batches you can manage in a day (cycle time). This helps bakers optimize their workflow to get the most cookies baked efficiently.
Balancing Machines for Efficiency
Chapter 7 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Another important thing as I mentioned earlier, we need to balance the interdependent machines, your scraper and pusher are interdependent machines, they work together. So, we have to balance them, we have to choose the correct number of scrapers and pushers, so that one need not wait for the other. So, we have to reduce the waiting time of the machines, so that we can reduce the cycle time, increase the productivity and reduce the production cost.
Detailed Explanation
To achieve a harmonious operation between scrapers and pushers, it is essential to maintain a balance in their numbers. A pusher should ideally serve multiple scrapers (4 to 5), based on their respective cycle times. By calculating the number of scrapers that can effectively be served by one pusher, waiting times can be minimized, leading to improved productivity and reduced costs.
Examples & Analogies
Just like a restaurant must balance the number of chefs and waitstaff to ensure customers are served promptly, construction teams must manage the number of scrapers and pushers. If there are too many scrapers for each pusher, they will be idle, wasting both time and resources, similar to customers waiting too long for their meals.
Key Concepts
-
Back-Track Loading: The slowest loading method that involves the pusher returning after loading.
-
Cycle Time: A measure of how long it takes to complete one complete operational cycle.
-
Chain Loading: An efficient method that eliminates backtrack time, suitable for long operations.
-
Shuttle Loading: A method using scrapers that operate in both directions for improved efficiency.
Examples & Applications
In a project involving road construction, chain loading reduces downtime effectively, allowing for continuous work.
When using the back-track loading method, if loading takes 3 minutes, the pusher may take an additional 2-3 minutes to backtrack.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
Pusher back, it's not fast, chain loading's here to last.
Stories
Imagine a busy road crew. The pusher is tired of returning, so it moves forward only to see another scraper slide up right next to it. That's chain loading!
Memory Tools
B - Back-track, C - Chain, S - Shuttle - Remember BCS for the three loading methods.
Acronyms
BCCS
for Backtrack
for Chain
for Shuttle.
Flash Cards
Glossary
- BackTrack Loading
A method where the pusher detaches and returns to pick up the next scraper after loading.
- Cycle Time
The total time taken for a machine to complete one cycle of work.
- Chain Loading
A method where the pusher remains stationary after loading one scraper and another scraper comes to it.
- Shuttle Loading
A loading method where the pusher switches between scrapers moving in opposite directions.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.