6.3 - Optimal Loading Time
Enroll to start learning
You’ve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
Back-Track Loading
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Today, we will discuss the first method of scraper loading, which is Back-Track Loading. Can anyone tell me what you think 'back-track' means in this context?
Isn't it when the pusher goes back to get the next scraper after loading the first one?
Exactly right, Student_1! In Back-Track Loading, once the first scraper, let's say Scraper 1, is fully loaded, the pusher detaches and moves back to find the next scraper.
But why is it considered the slowest method?
Great question! This method is the slowest because of the time consumed in backtracking. The pusher has to return a significant distance before it can start pushing the next scraper again. This increase in travel time can significantly affect productivity.
So, is that why most people prefer other methods?
Precisely! While the back-track method is widely used due to the preference for cutting in the same direction, it does result in longer loading cycles.
To summarize, Back-Track Loading is effective but slow because of return times. It's crucial to understand its limitations.
Chain Loading
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now let’s talk about Chain Loading. Who can tell me how Chain Loading differs from Back-Track Loading?
I think in Chain Loading, the pusher doesn’t have to go back after loading one scraper?
Exactly! In Chain Loading, once Scraper 1 is fully loaded, the pusher detaches and moves directly to the next scraper, which waits nearby, minimizing travel time.
What kind of projects is this method best suited for?
Chain Loading is most effective for long, narrow cuts like roads, where the two scrapers can closely coordinate their positions. This reduces the cycle time and speeds up the process significantly.
So it’s about proximity, right?
Exactly, Student_1! Lesser return travel time leads to efficient cycles. Remember, minimizing travel time is key for productivity!
In summary, Chain Loading helps improve efficiency by reducing return times, enhancing project speed.
Shuttle Loading
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Next up is Shuttle Loading. Can anyone explain where this method might be ideally used?
Is it used when there are fill areas on both sides?
Correct, Student_3! Shuttle Loading is effective in sites with fill areas in both directions. The pusher can alternate between scrapers moving in opposite directions.
So then it also reduces waiting time?
Yes! Because it minimizes return times, the cycle time for loading is greatly reduced, enhancing efficiency.
Is Shuttle Loading common like the others?
While it's effective, it's not as commonly adopted. However, understanding its use in specific conditions can greatly impact productivity!
In summary, Shuttle Loading is beneficial for operations with fill areas in both directions, offering reduced cycle time.
Optimizing Loading Times
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Let’s transition to calculating Pusher Cycle Time. How do we determine this?
Is there a formula we can use?
Absolutely! The formula is `Tp = 1.4Lt + 0.25`. Tp represents the pusher cycle time, and Lt is the loader time for the scraper.
What does each part of that formula mean?
Great follow-up, Student_3! The `1.4Lt` term considers the loading phase time, while the `0.25` accounts for positioning and any extra time needed. Calculating this helps us schedule effectively.
How do we make sure both scrapers and pushers are well balanced?
Balancing the number of scrapers and pushers is crucial! If you have too many scrapers compared to pushers, waiting times increase. The optimal way to balance is to use the formula: `N = Ts / Tp`, where N is the number of scrapers served by one pusher.
To sum up, proper calculations and balancing machines ensure reduced waiting times and increased productivity.
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
In this section, we explore three primary loading methods: back-track, chain, and shuttle loading. Each method has unique characteristics that affect loading times, with back-track being the slowest due to its return time, while chain and shuttle loading offer improved efficiencies under specific conditions. Additionally, a formula for calculating pusher cycle time and the importance of balancing scrapers and pushers to minimize waiting time is discussed.
Detailed
Detailed Summary
In this section, the concept of loading methods for scrapers is explored with a focus on optimizing loading time to enhance productivity in construction projects. Three main methods are discussed:
- Back-Track Loading: This method involves the pusher moving back to load the next scraper after the current one is fully loaded. While commonly adopted due to the preference for forward cutting, it is the slowest method because of the time spent returning to the next scraper.
- Chain Loading: Preferred for long, narrow cuts like roads, chain loading eliminates the need for the pusher to backtrack, allowing the next scraper to be positioned closely. This reduces cycle time significantly compared to back-track loading.
- Shuttle Loading: Although less common, this method is effective when there are fill areas in both directions. The pusher can switch directions and push scrapers loaded on opposite sides, further minimizing return time and optimizing cycles.
A crucial formula to determine the pusher cycle time (Tp) based on scraper load time (Lt) is provided: Tp = 1.4Lt + 0.25, promoting better time management. Furthermore, balancing the number of scrapers and pushers is essential to reduce waiting times, whereby one pusher can serve multiple scrapers, ensuring maximum productivity. The interdependence of scrapers and pushers is emphasized, showing that careful planning can lead to enhanced project efficiency.
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
Understanding Back-Track Loading
Chapter 1 of 11
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, once the loading of scraper 1 is completed, the pusher will back-track return back and spot the next a scraper, scraper 2 and start pushing it in the same direction. So, that is what is a back-track loading. So, first it is pushing the scraper 1, as a scraper 1 is completely loaded it will start moving on its own. Once the scraper 1 is loaded, your pusher will get detached and return that is backtracking, backtrack and it has to travel some distance and spot the next scraper 2. And then start pushing again in the same direction, it starts moving again in the same direction. So, that is what is your back-track loading method.
Detailed Explanation
Back-track loading is a method used during material loading where the pusher moves the first scraper (scraper 1) to the loading site. Once scraper 1 is completely loaded, the pusher detaches and travels back to find the next scraper (scraper 2) to push it. This method involves extra travel time since the pusher needs to backtrack before pushing the next scraper.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a train that picks up passengers at a station. Once the train is fully loaded with passengers, it leaves the station and must return to pick up more passengers from the next station. This back-and-forth travel makes the overall journey slower, just like the pusher in back-track loading.
Limitations of Back-Track Loading
Chapter 2 of 11
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, one limitation of this back-track loading method is it needs additional time for returning back backtracking. So, that is why we call this as a slowest method. So, this is the slowest of all the methods which we are going to discuss now. So, here you can see that the return time is more, return time is more because of the backtracking. So, everything the actual value will depend upon your project site.
Detailed Explanation
The main drawback of back-track loading is the extra time it requires for the pusher to return after loading the first scraper. This makes it the slowest loading method. The overall efficiency can vary depending on the specific setup of the project site, but typically, the need for backtracking delays the process.
Examples & Analogies
Consider a delivery person who needs to drop off packages at multiple locations. If after each delivery they must return to the depot before heading to the next location, each trip takes longer, much like how the pusher slows down in back-track loading by returning to pick up the next scraper.
Preference for Back-Track Loading
Chapter 3 of 11
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
But this is more commonly adopted by everyone because the people prefer the cutting in the same direction.
Detailed Explanation
Despite its limitations, back-track loading is widely used because it allows workers to maintain the same cutting direction. This consistency simplifies the loading process and can be easier to manage for workers, as they don’t have to adjust their movements frequently.
Examples & Analogies
Think of a chef who prefers to chop all vegetables in one consistent direction rather than switching directions each time they pick a new vegetable. This uniformity not only speeds up their work but also make it easier to maintain a rhythm in the kitchen.
Introduction to Chain Loading
Chapter 4 of 11
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
The next method which we are going to discuss is your chain loading method. So, this we commonly follow for long cuts, long narrow cuts like your roads, we can follow the chain loading method, say here your pusher is pushing the scraper 1, once a scraper 1 is completely loaded the scraper 1 is now in fully loaded condition. Now your pusher will get detached from the scraper 1 and the pusher start pushing the next scraper.
Detailed Explanation
Chain loading is used primarily for long and narrow cuts, such as those found in road construction. In this method, once scraper 1 is loaded, the pusher detaches and immediately starts pushing the next scraper (scraper 2) without needing to backtrack. This significantly reduces the return time.
Examples & Analogies
Consider a factory assembly line where one worker passes a fully assembled product directly to the next worker without any need to return to their workstation. This transfer method speeds up production much like how chain loading improves efficiency in material handling.
Advantages of Chain Loading
Chapter 5 of 11
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
But here is what happens the scraper 2 will come and wait near the pusher. Your pusher may not backtrack again; it may not return back again and spot the next scraper. So, the scraper 2 will come and wait near the pusher. So, this is commonly adopted in long roads, I mean long narrow cut like roads. So, here also since the returning time is reduced. So, you can say that the chain loading cycle time will be less.
Detailed Explanation
In chain loading, while scraper 2 waits next to the pusher, it removes the need for backtracking. This leads to shorter cycle times since the pusher can almost continuously push scrapers without the delays caused by returning to locate new scrapers.
Examples & Analogies
Like a relay race where one runner passes the baton to the next without stopping, chain loading allows scrapers to be loaded and moved in quick succession, enhancing speed and efficiency.
Overview of Shuttle Loading
Chapter 6 of 11
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
The next one is shuttle loading, this is not commonly followed, but you can follow it when you have 2 fill areas. That means you have a fill area in this direction as well as you have fill area in this direction. If you have fill areas in both the direction, then you can follow the shuttle loading.
Detailed Explanation
Shuttle loading is a less common method implemented when there are two filling areas in opposite directions. In this instance, the pusher will move back and forth between the two fill areas, enhancing flexibility and reducing overall cycle time.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a shuttle bus that runs between two different neighborhoods. It goes back and forth, picking up passengers from both places without needing to stay at one endpoint. This flexibility allows for efficient management of passenger transfers, similar to how shuttle loading works.
Comparing Loading Methods
Chapter 7 of 11
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, when you compare all these 3 methods, you can see that your back-track is the slowest method, the cycle time is relatively higher because it has to backtrack or return to support the next scraper but your chain and shuttle loading though they are not commonly followed so, but they are having the lesser cycle time and we know the reasons already.
Detailed Explanation
Overall, back-track loading is the slowest option due to the need for extra return trips. Chain and shuttle loading, while they may not be as frequently used, can lead to shorter cycle times because they reduce or eliminate backtracking.
Examples & Analogies
Think of various modes of transportation in a city. Some routes are slower due to detours (like back-track loading), while direct routes or intertwined public transit (like chain and shuttle loading) can shorten travel times significantly.
Summary of Key Points
Chapter 8 of 11
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, to summarize back-track loading method is the slowest of all the methods because of the additional pusher travel time for backtracking on returning. But most commonly followed because people prefer cutting in same direction. Chain loading, it is suited for long and narrow cut, here the return time is reduced. Shuttle loading requests 2 separate fill areas in both directions.
Detailed Explanation
Back-track loading, although slow due to return time, is popular for its directional consistency. Chain loading is efficient for road construction, and shuttle loading works well when there are two fill areas, allowing scrapers to operate in both directions.
Examples & Analogies
Just like a navigation app that suggests the best route based on traffic conditions, choosing the appropriate loading method based on project requirements helps ensure efficiency and effectiveness during construction.
The Formula for Cycle Time
Chapter 9 of 11
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, there is a thumb rule formula given by the caterpillar to determine the cycle time of the pusher, if you know the loading time of the scraper you can determine the cycle time of the pusher. Tp is the pusher cycle time and Lt is the scraper load time, the contact time of the pusher with your scraper during the loading phase of the scraper. So, if you know the loading time you can calculate the pusher time using this formula. Tp = 1.4Lt + 0.25.
Detailed Explanation
To calculate the cycle time of the pusher (Tp), you need to know the loading time of the scraper (Lt). The formula Tp = 1.4Lt + 0.25 helps predict how much time the pusher will spend working based on the loading time of the scraper. This is useful for planning and efficiency measurement.
Examples & Analogies
Think of it like budgeting time for a study session. If you know how long it takes to finish a chapter (scraper load time), you can estimate how long you need for your overall study (pusher cycle time), allowing you to plan your breaks and transitions effectively.
Balancing Scraper and Pusher Operations
Chapter 10 of 11
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Another important thing as I mentioned earlier, we need to balance the interdependent machines, your scraper and pusher are interdependent machines, they work together. So, we have to balance them, we have to choose the correct number of scrapers and pushers, so that one need not wait for the other.
Detailed Explanation
Balancing the number of scrapers and pushers is crucial for efficient operation. If one machine has to wait for the other, production slows down. Therefore, it is necessary to determine the appropriate number of each to minimize waiting times and maintain productivity in construction projects.
Examples & Analogies
Like a well-coordinated dance duet, each dancer needs to know when to step forward or back to keep the performance flowing without pauses or stumbles. In construction, the balance between scrapers and pushers ensures that tasks are completed swiftly and efficiently.
Calculating Number of Scrapers for a Pusher
Chapter 11 of 11
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, how to find the number of scrapers which can be served by one pusher? As I told you pusher cycle time is less it is assisting the scraper only during the loading phase of the scraper. So, one pusher can serve even 4 to 5 scrapers. So, now how to determine the number of scrapers served by 1 pusher? So, N is the number of scrapers served by one pusher, it is equal to cycle time of the scraper divided by a cycle time to pusher. This gives you the balanced number. So, N = Ts / Tp.
Detailed Explanation
To determine how many scrapers can be served by a single pusher, you calculate the ratio of the cycle time of the scraper (Ts) to the pusher’s cycle time (Tp). Typically, one pusher can effectively serve 4 to 5 scrapers, which maximizes efficiency without delays.
Examples & Analogies
Think of a queue at a coffee shop where each barista can only serve a limited number of customers at once. Knowing how many customers each barista can handle helps ensure that there are enough baristas to keep the line moving without keeping anyone waiting for too long.
Key Concepts
-
Back-Track Loading: The slowest loading method due to return time.
-
Chain Loading: Involves scrapers waiting near the pusher and is efficient for narrow cuts.
-
Shuttle Loading: Effective for fill areas in both directions, reducing cycle time.
-
Cycle Time Calculation: Understanding how to calculate pusher cycle time is crucial for efficiency.
-
Balancing Machines: The importance of equally managing scrapers and pushers to minimize waiting times.
Examples & Applications
A construction project involving the excavation of a long, narrow road could greatly benefit from Chain Loading due to minimized return times.
In a project where fill zones are located on both sides, employing Shuttle Loading allows continuous operation with reduced idle time.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
To load with less strife, don’t let pushers lose life; Chain it up, minimize time, or Shuttle swift—it’s prime!
Stories
Imagine a pusher on a mission. First, it backtracks to find the next scraper, becoming slow. Then, it uses a chain, skipping back, efficiently loading the next scraper near by. Finally, it finds a way to work both sides quickly, pushing scrapers towards fill areas in both directions.
Memory Tools
Remember the ABCs of loading: A for Back-track, S for Shuttle, and C for Chain to navigate all loading methods.
Acronyms
BSC
**B**ack
**S**huttle
**C**hain—different ways to load
each with a name!
Flash Cards
Glossary
- BackTrack Loading
A loading method where the pusher returns to load the next scraper after one is fully loaded, resulting in longer cycle times.
- Chain Loading
A loading method where the next scraper waits near the pusher to minimize return times and improve efficiency, suitable for long cuts.
- Shuttle Loading
A method suitable for configurations with fill areas in both directions, allowing the pusher to switch directions and push different scrapers efficiently.
- Cycle Time
The total time required to complete a loading, travel, and unloading process for the machine.
- Pusher
The machine responsible for pushing scrapers during the loading process.
- Scraper
A machine used for loading, hauling, dumping, and spreading materials.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.