3 - Productivity Estimation of the Scraper
Enroll to start learning
You’ve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
Understanding Swell Factors
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Today, we will discuss the swell factor. Can anyone tell me what a swell factor represents in earthmoving?
Isn't it the ratio between loose and bank dry unit weight?
Exactly! Now, for dry earth, the swell factor is given as 0.80. When using pushers, we must remember that this can increase by 10% due to additional compaction. So what would be the swell factor we consider when working with push-loaded scrapers?
That would be 0.88, right?
Great memory! This is crucial for calculating effective load volumes. Remember: Swell Factor = Loose Dry Unit Weight / Bank Dry Unit Weight.
So it's important to adjust the swell factor based on the loading technique!
Absolutely! This affects how much material we can effectively load into the scraper before hitting diminishing returns.
To summarize, the swell factor impacts loading capacity significantly, especially when pushers are involved.
Cycle Time Calculations
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Let's now move on to calculating cycle times. What are some components we need to consider for a scraper's cycle time?
We need to look at loading time, dump time, travel time, and turn time, right?
Exactly! Based on our earlier problem statement, can anyone give me the average loading time?
That would be 0.80 minutes.
Correct! And the average dumping time is 0.37 minutes. To find the total cycle time, we sum these along with travel times. Can anyone calculate it?
If we add those up, we will still need to factor in the traveling times as well, like the 6.1 minutes we derived earlier!
So it would end up being around 7.78 minutes in total for the scraper cycle!
Excellent! Your understanding here will ensure that we have the right timing for balancing scraper and pusher operations.
Balancing Scraper and Pusher Operations
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now, let’s discuss the concept of balancing scrapers and pushers. Why do we need to balance these machines?
To avoid delays and ensure that one doesn't wait too long for the other?
Exactly! If one pusher can serve multiple scrapers, how do we calculate the balanced number of scrapers?
We take the cycle time of the scraper divided by that of the pusher!
That's right! With a scraper cycle of 7.78 minutes and a pusher cycle of 1.37 minutes, what does that give us?
That would be approximately 5.68 scrapers, but we have to round it!
Correct! Based on operational efficiency, we could serve either 5 or 6 scrapers. Remember, it’s important to evaluate the economics of each to make a decision.
To summarize, balancing scrapers and pushers helps minimize waiting times and maximize productivity.
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
In this section, the productivity estimation of scrapers is explored through practical calculations. Key concepts such as swell factors, machine weights, and haul routes are discussed, along with sample problems to balance the use of scrapers and pushers to enhance productivity and minimize costs.
Detailed
Detailed Summary
In this section, we delve into the productivity estimation for scrapers used in construction. The discussion is centered around operational parameters and physical properties of materials, such as the unit weight of dry earth and the relevant swell factors affecting the hauling capacity of scrapers. The combination of scrapers and pushers plays a vital role in enhancing productivity during earth-moving operations.
Key Points Covered:
- Materials & Properties: The section specifies the unit weight of dry soil (1660 kg/m³) and introduces the swell factor (0.80), with an increased swell factor of 10% due to the compaction that occurs when using push-loaded scrapers.
- Cycle Time Estimation: Cycle times for loading, dumping, and travel are calculated and included. For instance, the average loading and dump times are provided (0.80 minutes and 0.37 minutes, respectively), which contribute to understanding total scraper cycle times.
- Operational Efficiency: The efficiency of the scraper and pusher operations is defined, indicating that during one hour, the machine operates efficiently for only 50 minutes.
- Cost Analysis: Ownership and operating costs for the scraper and pusher are given (4500 and 5600 Rupees/hour) respectively, emphasizing budgeting concerns in machinery use.
- Balancing Machines: The section concludes with ways to balance the number of scrapers and pushers based on their respective cycle times, highlighting that one pusher can serve multiple scrapers efficiently to maximize productivity.
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
Introduction to Productivity Estimation
Chapter 1 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, now, let us work on the first problem on productivity estimation of the scraper. So, a scraper with the assistance of the pusher is moving the dry earth soil having unit weight of 1660 kg per bank meter cube. So, you can see that this is a conventional pusher loaded scraper, here we are moving the material which is dry earth soil, its unit weight is given 1660 kg per bank meter cube.
Detailed Explanation
In this chunk, we are introduced to the productivity estimation process for a scraper. The scraper, with help from a pusher, is designed to move dry earth soil, which has a specific weight that is given in the material description. This unit weight (1660 kg/m³) is crucial in calculating how much material the scraper can effectively move during operation. By understanding these parameters, we can estimate the scraper's productivity effectively.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine you are using a wheelbarrow to move soil. If you know the weight of the soil you are carrying, you can determine how many trips you can make in an hour. Similarly, knowing the weight of the earth being moved helps businesses decide how many scrapers they need for a job.
Understanding the Swell Factor
Chapter 2 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, the volume is given in volumetric measures is a bank state. So, that you have to clearly note it and the swell factor has given as 0.80. So, with the help of the swell factor you can do the conversion like from loose volume, you can convert it into bank volume or vice versa.
Detailed Explanation
The swell factor plays a significant role in estimating productivity because it represents the ratio of loose material to compacted material. For example, if soil is disturbed, it can expand or swell, meaning when calculating how much fits in the scraper, you must adjust for this factor. Here, the swell factor is 0.80, indicating that for every cubic meter of loose material, it has a compacted volume of 0.8 cubic meters.
Examples & Analogies
Think of fluffing up a pillow. If you fill a pillow with stuffing, it appears larger than it is when compressed. Similarly, soil expands when it is moved, and the swell factor helps us calculate how much space it will take once disturbed.
Impact of Pusher on Swell Factor
Chapter 3 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
You should know that this swell factor will increase by 10 % due to pushing. Why is it particularly for the push loaded scrapers? Your swell factor increases by 10 % due to pushing. So, basically, you know that when the pusher is pushing the scraper. It offers more additional pressure to push more material into the bowl.
Detailed Explanation
The swell factor for push-loaded scrapers increases due to the additional pressure exerted by the pusher on the material in the scraper bowl. This added pressure compresses the loose material more, making it denser and increasing its weight per cubic meter. As a result, we must adjust our calculations to account for this increased weight when estimating how much material the scraper can effectively carry.
Examples & Analogies
Think of a suitcase that can only hold 20 pounds of clothes. If you sit on it and push down as you zip it up, you can fit more clothes than you could without applying that pressure. Similarly, the pusher allows the scraper to carry heavier loads.
Calculating Rolling Resistance and Haul Routes
Chapter 4 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, assume the rolling resistance of 50 kg per ton for this particular haul route the rolling resistance is 50 kg per ton. So, if you want to convert it into equivalent gradient, you know that for 1% is a gradient equal to 10 kg per ton.
Detailed Explanation
Rolling resistance is the force resisting the motion when a body (in this case, the scraper and pusher) rolls on a surface. Here, it's quantified as 50 kg per ton. This ensures we understand how much force is required to move the scraper. The conversion from the rolling resistance into gradient helps visualize how steep the incline would be, which is especially useful in planning the path of movement for the scraper.
Examples & Analogies
When riding a bicycle uphill, you know it requires more effort than riding on flat ground. The rolling resistance helps us understand how much 'work' the scraper has to do against the ground to move forward.
Understanding Machine Capacity and Loading Factors
Chapter 5 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Heaped capacity the scraper is given as 23.70 meter cube. They expect the load will be 95% of the heaped capacity. So, that means as we discussed earlier, we are not going to load the scraper to its fullest capacity.
Detailed Explanation
The heaped capacity gives us the maximum volume the scraper can hold when fully loaded, which in this case is 23.70 cubic meters. However, practical considerations, such as efficiency and machine performance, recommend loading only up to 95% (approximately 22.52 m³). This accounts for diminishing returns, implying that overly full scrapers may not operate at optimal efficiency, leading to longer loading times.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine filling a backpack with books. If you fill it to the brim, carrying it becomes much harder and awkward, slowing you down. However, if you leave a little space, the backpack is easier to carry and maneuver.
Estimation of Production Costs
Chapter 6 of 6
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So, now we are going to analyze and find the probable scraper production and also find the cost to move a bank meter cube of material. So, you have to find the unit cost of production cost per bank meter cube.
Detailed Explanation
Calculating the production costs involves determining how much it costs to move one cubic meter of material with the scraper. By analyzing factors like efficiency factors, operating costs, and cycle times, you can create a comprehensive assessment of how much money is spent for each volume of material moved. This is crucial for project planning and budgeting.
Examples & Analogies
Consider a pizza shop calculating the cost per pizza. They total up ingredients, labor, and overhead costs to determine what each pizza costs to make, enabling them to price it profitably.
Key Concepts
-
Swell Factor: Represents the change in volume of soil when disturbed, important for load calculations.
-
Gross Weight: Total weight of the scraper including the load, vital for calculating operational capabilities.
-
Cycle Time: Duration taken to complete one full operation cycle, affects productivity estimates.
-
Balancing Machines: Important strategy to optimize productivity by aligning the operational efficiencies of scrapers and pushers.
Examples & Applications
If a scraper has a heaped capacity of 23.7 m³ but operates at 95% efficiency, the load capacity is 22.52 m³.
Given the swell factor of 0.80 for dry earth, converting loose volume into bank volume for operational plans is crucial.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
To remember swell factor's might, load is light and bank is tight.
Stories
Imagine a baker measuring flour. The fluffier the flour, the more it weighs. This is like the swell factor; the well-packed bank volume fills less than the loose fluff.
Memory Tools
Remember SCRAP for loading details: Swell, Capacity, Resistance, Average loading, Pusher cycle.
Acronyms
S.C.R.A.P. = Swell factor, Capacity of scrapers, Resistance, Average loading time, Pusher times.
Flash Cards
Glossary
- Swell Factor
The ratio of loose dry unit weight to bank dry unit weight of soil, indicative of expansion when the soil is disturbed.
- Cycle Time
The time taken for a complete operation cycle of a machine, including all phases of loading, travel, and dumping.
- Gross Weight
The total weight of the machine, including its empty weight and the weight of the load it carries.
- Pusher Cycle Time
The duration needed for a pusher to assist a scraper in completing the loading phase.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.