4.5 - Advantages and Disadvantages of Photogrammetry
Enroll to start learning
You’ve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
Understanding advantages
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Let's explore the advantages of photogrammetry. Can anyone tell me why it might be advantageous over traditional surveying?
It covers large areas quickly, right?
Absolutely! Photogrammetry provides an economical way to map extensive areas efficiently. It captures a permanent pictorial record of the landscape at a specific point in time, which is invaluable.
Does that mean we can use it in dangerous places too?
Yes! It’s particularly useful for getting data from unsafe or inaccessible areas. Let's remember this acronym: SAFETY - S for 'Safe access to hazardous areas' and A for 'Aerial views.'
So we can minimize fieldwork and still collect accurate data?
Exactly! It reduces the need for extensive fieldwork by allowing office-based processing of collected images.
What about the ability to update the data? Is that an advantage too?
Great observation! New aerial images can easily update previous data without the need to remap everything. In summary, photogrammetry's advantages include cost-effectiveness, safety, efficiency, and flexibility in data updating.
Discussing disadvantages
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now, let's look into the disadvantages of photogrammetry. What challenges do you think we might face?
Maybe it requires special equipment or skills?
Correct! Processing aerial photographs does need experienced technical manpower. It's a critical point to ensure that we have skilled personnel for analysis.
What about weather conditions? Could that affect the photographs?
Exactly! Factors such as wind, clouds, and haze can impact the quality of photographs captured. Always consider weather in your planning!
But isn’t there a limitation in mapping areas with tall buildings or trees?
Yes, that's another disadvantage. Ground information obstructed by urban structures may not be as accurately mapped. This emphasizes the importance of planning where to take photographs.
Are there limitations in costs for developing countries?
Yes, aerial photography can be expensive, particularly for countries needing repetitive coverage for large-scale mapping. In summary, while photogrammetry holds many advantages, we must be aware of the skilled labor requirements, weather conditions, obstructions to visibility, and economic constraints.
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
This section discusses the advantages of photogrammetry, such as cost-effectiveness and utility in hazardous areas, alongside disadvantages including dependence on technical expertise and environmental conditions that can impact the quality of aerial photographs.
Detailed
Photogrammetry provides a permanent visual record of areas, making it a valuable method for efficient and accurate mapping over large regions. Its advantages include enhanced safety in accessing hazardous areas, minimization of fieldwork, and the capacity for revising previous data using newer images. However, there are significant disadvantages such as the need for skilled personnel for image processing, susceptibility to atmospheric conditions affecting photograph quality, and limitations in mapping certain features obscured by urban infrastructure. The balance between these pros and cons is crucial for determining when and how to effectively utilize photogrammetry in surveying and mapping applications.
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
Disadvantages of Photogrammetry
Chapter 1 of 1
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
- Requires experienced technical manpower for processing and analysis of aerial photographs.
- Necessitates advance flight planning and specialized equipment and aircraft.
- Affected by atmospheric conditions, such as winds, clouds, and haze, which can compromise quality.
- Seasonal conditions, like snow cover, can obstruct features in photographs.
- Ground details obscured by high-rise buildings or dense tree canopies cannot be accurately mapped.
- Accuracy of contours and cross-sections rely on the quality of the 3D models generated, which is influenced by the scale of photographs and the number of ground control points.
- Aerial photography can be prohibitively expensive, particularly for developing countries requiring repetitive coverage.
- Legal constraints may restrict aerial photography in sensitive or restricted areas.
Detailed Explanation
Despite its numerous advantages, photogrammetry does have certain disadvantages. For instance, it requires seasoned professionals who are skilled in processing and analyzing aerial photographs. This need for expertise can lead to increased costs and time delays if the personnel are not readily available.
Additionally, the method relies heavily on meticulous flight planning and the use of specialized equipment and aircraft, which requires investment and may not be feasible for all organizations, especially smaller firms or those in developing nations.
Another significant challenge is the impact of weather conditions; elements such as wind, clouds, or haze can impair the quality of images, leading to inaccurate results. Similarly, seasonal changes like snow may cover features that would otherwise be visible, complicating the mapping process.
Moreover, obstacles such as tall buildings or dense vegetation pose challenges to capturing accurate ground-level information. If a crucial feature is hidden behind these obstacles, it complicates or prevents accurate mapping altogether.
Moreover, the accuracy of the generated 3D models, which are essential for tasks like producing contours and cross-sections, heavily depends on the quality of the photographs taken and the ground control points used in model generation. If these parameters are not carefully managed, the output can lack precision.
Lastly, the cost of repeated aerial photography can be substantial, making it hard to justify for repeated monitoring in economically challenged regions. Legal restrictions in specific areas can further limit aerial photography, creating hurdles for comprehensive mapping.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a photographer wanting to take stunning aerial shots of a city for a travel magazine. While it sounds exciting, the photographer soon realizes they require special equipment and expertise to effectively capture the images from a drone. Plus, they also need to coordinate their shots on a clear sunny day without clouds—if it's too windy or rainy, all their efforts could end in blurry images.
Now think about neighborhoods in the city. The photographer might find that a few tall buildings block their view of certain streets or parks, ruining their chance to showcase those bustling areas. This situation depicts the hurdles faced when attempting to utilize aerial photography—an exciting tool, but not without its own set of challenges.
Key Concepts
-
Permanent Record: Photogrammetry creates a permanent visual record of the area.
-
Cost Efficiency: It is usually more economical than traditional survey methods.
-
Safety Advantages: Ideal for accessing hazardous areas.
-
Dependence on Expertise: Requires skilled personnel for image analysis.
-
Weather Sensitivity: Quality of aerial photographs can be affected by atmospheric conditions.
Examples & Applications
In mining operations, photogrammetry allows safe mapping of hazardous terrains without sending personnel into potentially dangerous areas.
Urban planners can harness aerial photographs to update maps and monitor changes in city landscapes over time.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
In the sky, a view so bright, Photogrammetry makes the mapping right!
Stories
Imagine an explorer who can see entire landscapes from above without stepping foot on dangerous terrain. With photogrammetry, they can create maps swiftly and efficiently while staying safe.
Memory Tools
To remember advantages, think SAFE DATA: Safety, Accessibility, Flexibility, Efficiency, Data record.
Acronyms
For disadvantages
CHANCE - Cost
Hidden features
Atmospheric impact
Need for skill
Constraints in visibility
Expensive.
Flash Cards
Glossary
- Photogrammetry
The art, science, and technology of obtaining reliable information about physical objects through processes of recording, measuring, and interpreting photographic images.
- Aerial Photography
Photographs taken from an aircraft or drone, often used in mapping and surveying.
- Control Points
Reference points with known three-dimensional coordinates used for calibration in photogrammetric processes.
- Relief Displacement
The apparent shift of an object’s position in an aerial photograph due to topographical variations.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.