Difference Between Interrupt Driven I/O and DMA Transfer
Enroll to start learning
You’ve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
Introduction to Interrupt-Driven I/O
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Today, we are going to discuss interrupt-driven I/O. Can someone tell me what happens when an interrupt occurs?
The CPU stops its current task to address the interrupt, right?
Exactly! The CPU changes context, meaning it switches to handle the interrupt. This can cause delays due to busy waiting. Can you name some consequences of this?
It seems inefficient, especially if many interrupts stack up.
Right. That's a crucial point. Remember this acronym I-C-U: Interrupt causes CPU Uncertainty. It exemplifies how interruptions can make processing unpredictable.
I can see how that might slow down operations.
Exactly! Now let's summarize: Interrupt-driven I/O changes the context of the CPU, slows down processing, and can create wait states. Let's move to DMA.
Understanding DMA
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now, let’s explore DMA. What do you think DMA stands for?
Direct Memory Access!
Correct! DMA allows the transfer of data directly from I/O devices to memory, bypassing the CPU. What benefits can this provide?
The CPU won't be halted, so it can keep working on other tasks!
Exactly! In DMA, the bus control is managed by the DMA controller, minimizing CPU suspension. Let's design a memory aid for DMA: you can call it 'D-M-A: Data Move Accurately!'
That’s catchy! It helps me remember that data moves accurately without CPU interruption.
Perfect! In summary, DMA allows for simultaneous processing while managing bulk data transfers effectively.
Modes of DMA Transfer
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Let’s talk about the two modes of DMA transfer. Who remembers what they are?
Burst mode and cycle stealing mode!
Excellent! In burst mode, the entire data set is transferred in one go, but what happens afterward?
The CPU has to wait longer to regain control of the bus.
Correct! Now, how does cycle stealing mode work?
It allows the DMA controller to transfer data and then temporarily gives the bus back to the CPU!
Exactly! Let's summarize: Burst mode transfers all at once, while cycle stealing optimizes bus use by giving the CPU intermittent access.
Challenges with DMA and Design Choices
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Let’s consider some challenges with DMA. Can anyone share an issue we might face?
Would it be having to coordinate multiple I/O devices?
Exactly! DMA must coordinate multiple devices effectively. There are different configurations: what happens if we connect multiple devices to a single bus?
The CPU will have to wait longer, as it can be interrupted more frequently.
Well said! Let's use the acronym B-U-S: Bus Utilization Suspended. It represents how a busy bus affects processor operations.
That’s an interesting way to remember it!
In summary, DMA needs careful configuration to optimize performance and minimize interruptions.
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
This section outlines how interrupt-driven I/O involves a change of context, requiring CPU intervention for data transfer, whereas DMA transfer allows the CPU to continue processing while data is transferred directly to or from memory, avoiding context changes.
Detailed
Detailed Summary
In the context of computer architecture, the method of data transfer can significantly impact performance. This section distinguishes between two primary data transfer techniques: interrupt-driven I/O and Direct Memory Access (DMA).
1. Interrupt-Driven I/O: This method necessitates a change of context whenever an interrupt occurs. The CPU momentarily pauses its current task to handle the interrupt, which can lead to inefficiencies, as the CPU must repeatedly check for interrupts—this technique is often referred to as busy waiting. When data needs to be transferred, the CPU must process a request from the I/O device, which can cause delays depending on the complexity of the data and the frequency of the interrupts. Here, the CPU can only execute the following instruction after processing the interrupt.
2. Direct Memory Access (DMA): In this transfer method, the DMA controller takes over the bus and facilitates data transfers without CPU intervention, thus preventing context switches. During DMA transfer, the CPU can continue executing other tasks if it has any operational data available in its buffers. The operation can either be a burst transfer mode, where data is moved in a single operation, or cycle stealing mode, where the DMA controller temporarily yields bus access back to the CPU intermittently. This allows for more balanced processor utilization while minimizing idle times.
Through contrasting these two methods, the section also explores the architectural considerations behind implementing a DMA controller and the bus configurations for optimal performance, ultimately highlighting the advantages of DMA in enhancing system throughput.
Youtube Videos
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
Context Switching in I/O Types
Chapter 1 of 5
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
In case of interrupt driven I/O, here is a change of context. In case of DMA transfer, there is no context change, the context of the processor remains the same whatever program it is executing.
Detailed Explanation
When using interrupt driven I/O, the processor needs to pause its current task to handle the interrupt. This scenario leads to a change in context because it interrupts the program execution in progress. On the other hand, with DMA (Direct Memory Access), the processor can continue executing its current program as the DMA controller takes over the data transfer directly between memory and I/O devices. This means that the processor's current task is not interrupted.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a chef who is preparing a meal (the processor) and has to stop to answer a phone call (interrupt driven I/O). After the call, the chef returns to the meal preparation. In contrast, if a waiter (DMA) takes care of serving food to customers without disturbing the chef, the chef can finish the meal preparation without interruption.
Operation of CPU During DMA
Chapter 2 of 5
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
CPU is suspended just before it accesses the bus. The processor can carry out its own work, but it cannot fetch some data if the bus is now with the DMA controller.
Detailed Explanation
Before a DMA operation starts, the CPU gets suspended briefly as it can't access the data bus. This means that while the DMA controller is handling the transfer, the CPU cannot fetch new data needed for its ongoing tasks. However, if there are instructions already in the CPU's instruction buffer, it can still execute those until it needs new data.
Examples & Analogies
Think of a worker (the CPU) who is writing a report but needs to wait for a colleague (DMA) to finish printing documents. The worker can keep working on parts of the report that don’t require the printed documents, but cannot finish the report until they get the necessary printed pieces.
DMA Transfer Modes
Chapter 3 of 5
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
In case of DMA transfer, there are two modes of data transfer: burst transfer mode and cycle stealing mode.
Detailed Explanation
In burst transfer mode, the DMA controller takes control of the bus and transfers a large amount of data in one go, which can cause the CPU to wait for a longer time during this transfer. In contrast, in cycle stealing mode, the DMA controller transfers one piece of data at a time and then gives control back to the CPU to do some processing before taking control again. This allows the CPU to perform its tasks intermittently, reducing wait time but prolonging the overall transfer time.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a large shipment (data) being loaded at a warehouse. In burst mode, a large truck (DMA controller) comes and takes all the boxes in one trip, leaving the warehouse idle for a long time. In cycle stealing mode, smaller vans (each carrying one box) come and go, allowing the warehouse staff (CPU) to continue working in between the van trips.
Difference in Interrupt Handling
Chapter 4 of 5
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
In case of interrupts, the processor checks for interruptions only after completing the current instruction, while DMA may require suspension at different points.
Detailed Explanation
When a processor receives an interrupt, it finishes executing the current instruction first before checking for the interrupt. In contrast, during DMA transfers, the CPU could be suspended at various points of execution depending on whether it needs to fetch new instructions or data, often resulting in different suspension points compared to the single breakpoint in interrupt handling.
Examples & Analogies
Think of a student (CPU) taking a test (current execution) who only reviews any interruptions (interrupts) after finishing the test. On the other hand, a project manager (during DMA) who is juggling multiple tasks must often pause each time another task requires their attention, creating multiple interruptions.
Bus Configuration for DMA
Chapter 5 of 5
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
The DMA controller can be connected in various configurations, affecting how often the CPU will be suspended during data transfer.
Detailed Explanation
The configuration of the bus affecting the DMA's operation can vary: in one setup, both the I/O device and DMA controller share a single bus, requiring multiple suspensions for data transfer. Alternatively, if I/O devices connect through the DMA controller, the CPU may only be suspended once during the entire data transfer process, streamlining operations.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a delivery service where all packages (data) must pass through a single checkpoint (bus). If each package has to stop at the checkpoint and wait (multiple suspensions), it takes longer. But if the checkpoint has dedicated lanes for different packages (different bus configurations), the packages can move smoothly with fewer stops, expediting overall deliveries.
Key Concepts
-
Interrupt-driven I/O: Involves context switches that slow down CPU processing.
-
Direct Memory Access: Allows data transfers without interrupting CPU tasks.
-
Burst Transfer: DMA transfers data all at once.
-
Cycle Stealing: DMA intermittently transfers data back and forth with the CPU.
Examples & Applications
In interrupt-driven I/O, when an input device signals data is ready, the CPU stops its current process to handle the data transfer.
During DMA, if a hard disk needs to transfer data to memory, the DMA controller takes over the bus, allowing other operations to continue concurrently.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
In DMA, the CPU can play, while data moves away!
Stories
Imagine a busy highway where an ambulance (DMA) can pass through while regular traffic (CPU) keeps moving without stops!
Memory Tools
Remember I-C-U: Interruptions Can Unsettle the pace of CPU operations!
Acronyms
DMA
Directly Manage Access
Flash Cards
Glossary
- DMA (Direct Memory Access)
A method that allows peripherals to transfer data directly to and from memory without CPU intervention.
- InterruptDriven I/O
A process where the CPU is interrupted to handle I/O operations, often causing context switches.
- Context Change
The process of switching the CPU’s attention from one task to another, often leading to performance delays.
- Burst Transfer
A DMA mode where a full set of data is transferred in a single operation.
- Cycle Stealing
A DMA mode where data transfer is performed intermittently, allowing the CPU to access the bus at intervals.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.