3.1 - Differences in Relocation Approaches
Enroll to start learning
You’ve not yet enrolled in this course. Please enroll for free to listen to audio lessons, classroom podcasts and take practice test.
Interactive Audio Lesson
Listen to a student-teacher conversation explaining the topic in a relatable way.
Introduction to Kiruna's Relocation
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Today, we're going to talk about the relocation of heritage buildings in Kiruna. Can anyone tell me why this relocation is necessary?
Is it because of the mining activities happening around?
Exactly! The LKAB mining company is causing some structural issues in Kiruna. This highlights the need to understand the role of stakeholders in such a complex situation. What are the key stakeholders involved here?
Well, there's the LKAB company and the local government, Kiruna Kommun, right?
And the local community too!
Great point! Remember, we can refer to these three stakeholders as ‘K-L-C’ for LKAB, Kiruna Kommun, and Community to help us remember them. Now, can anyone explain the concept of 'heritagisation'?
Understanding Heritagisation
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
The term 'heritagisation' refers to the process of recognizing buildings as heritage. Can anyone explain why this is important for Kiruna?
It's important so that the history and significance of these buildings are acknowledged before they get moved.
Exactly! We have also seen re-heritagisation, where some buildings are reaffirmed for their importance. Can anyone describe what 'de-heritagisation' means?
It's when some buildings are deemed less important and may not be relocated.
Correct! It's crucial to be mindful of which buildings hold value. A good acronym to remember these three processes is H-R-D: Heritagisation, Re-heritagisation, De-heritagisation.
Stakeholder Perspectives
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Now let's discuss the perspectives of our three stakeholders. How might LKAB view the relocation?
They probably see it from a financial perspective—they want to minimize costs.
Right. And what about the community's perspective? How might they feel about moving?
They may be concerned about losing their connection to their history and homes.
Exactly! It's a delicate balance, ensuring the community's values and heritage are respected. Remember this complexity with the mnemonic C-L-M: Community, LKAB, and Minimized impact!
Practical Considerations in Relocation
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
Relocating buildings isn't just about the sentimental value; practical considerations are vital as well. What sorts of practical challenges do you think might occur?
There could be huge costs involved in moving these buildings.
Yes, that’s one of the key challenges, especially with historic buildings that may have intricate designs. Can anyone think of another practical complication?
Weather conditions could delay the process too.
You're spot on! Harsh weather must be considered when planning. Let's remember this with the acronym C-C-W: Costs, Conditions, and Weather.
Future Implications of the Relocation
🔒 Unlock Audio Lesson
Sign up and enroll to listen to this audio lesson
As we think about the future, what do you all think Kiruna should prioritize during its relocation?
They need to focus on maintaining the heritage and identity of the town.
Absolutely! Balancing modern needs with historical preservation is crucial. And what about the environmental aspects?
They should consider the impact on the local ecosystem and wildlife!
Great points! Let's remember this with the mnemonic H-E-E: Heritage, Environment, and Economics.
Introduction & Overview
Read summaries of the section's main ideas at different levels of detail.
Quick Overview
Standard
In Kiruna, the relocation of heritage buildings due to mining activities poses significant challenges, as different stakeholders like LKAB, Kiruna Kommun, and residents have varying perspectives on the importance and future of these buildings. The heritagisation process highlights the balancing act between preserving history and addressing practical relocation needs.
Detailed
Differences in Relocation Approaches
This section discusses the intricate challenges faced in the relocation of heritage buildings in Kiruna, Sweden. As the town prepares to move due to mining activities, three primary stakeholders emerge: LKAB (the mining company), the Kiruna Kommun (municipality), and the local community. The interactions among these entities complicate the relocation process, affecting how heritage is recognized and preserved. Jennie Sjoholm's work in analyzing existing documentation provides insights into the conservation efforts and the differing jargon that explains the roles and intentions of these stakeholders.
Key elements of the heritagisation process include:
1. Heritagisation: The acknowledgment and formal recognition of heritage sites.
2. Re-heritagisation: Recognizing the importance of buildings that will be preserved and relocated.
3. De-heritagisation: Deciding which buildings may not be worth relocating.
An important debate centers around what narratives of history will be told about Kiruna and its future, emphasizing the importance of careful planning amidst uncertainties and financial calculations. In contrast to less mindful approaches observed globally, Sweden's process takes into account environmental concerns, ensuring that relocations consider both human and ecological impacts.
Audio Book
Dive deep into the subject with an immersive audiobook experience.
Importance of Heritage in Relocation
Chapter 1 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
We cannot, it is not easy to demolish these important buildings and then we are going to construct a new set of image because it is to play with the peoples emotions peoples belonging.
Detailed Explanation
This chunk highlights the significance of preserving heritage buildings during the relocation process. It suggests that demolishing these buildings is not just a logistical decision; it affects people's emotions and their sense of belonging in the community. Hence, it's essential to consider how such actions can impact the local identity and emotional connections of residents.
Examples & Analogies
Think of a family home that holds generations of memories. If the family has to leave that home, it’s not just about the physical space; it represents their history and connections. Similarly, in towns, heritage buildings symbolize the community’s identity.
Stakeholders in Kiruna's Relocation
Chapter 2 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
you have these 3 are the major stakeholders of the Kiruna one is the railway the other one is the LKAB state-owned mining company and the other one is the Kiruna Kommun to serve the people.
Detailed Explanation
In Kiruna, the relocation process involves three major stakeholders: the railway company, LKAB (the state-owned mining company), and the Kiruna Kommun (municipality). Each of these entities has a significant role in the relocation process, as they contribute financially, administratively, and socially to the planning and execution of the move.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a school fundraising event where teachers, parents, and students all play different roles. The teachers plan the event, parents provide resources, and students help with logistics. Just like in this scenario, each stakeholder in Kiruna has a distinct responsibility that is crucial for the success of the relocation.
Heritagisation Process Initiated
Chapter 3 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
And here the heritagisation have actually referred to various aspects; one is the addition of new heritage because when they came to know that yes the Kiruna is going to move further.
Detailed Explanation
The term 'heritagisation' refers to the process by which certain buildings or areas are recognized as heritage due to their historical value. In Kiruna, as relocation plans emerged, there was a push to identify and preserve new heritage sites alongside established ones, reflecting changes in community identity and recognizing the need to safeguard important structures during the move.
Examples & Analogies
Think of a town deciding to celebrate a new park that was built to preserve nature. As new developments come in, communities often designate new landmarks or parks as heritage sites, acknowledging their significance to the community's history and culture.
Controversies in Heritage Management
Chapter 4 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
Let us see how it went, and there have been a lot of the controversial aspects of how this particular culture has going to be taken into account in the move process.
Detailed Explanation
The relocation process in Kiruna involves controversies regarding how different cultural aspects are considered. The decision on which buildings are preserved or relocated raises debates about the narrative of history that will be told in the future. This reflects a struggle between maintaining heritage and the realities of modern development.
Examples & Analogies
Consider a community voting on which historical site to preserve while a new shopping mall is built. Some may want to save the old community center, believing it’s an essential piece of their history, while others may prioritize the development of new infrastructure. This tension encapsulates the dilemmas faced during heritage management.
Heritagisation, Re-heritagisation, and De-heritagisation
Chapter 5 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
One is a heritagisation, re-heritagisation and de-heritagisation.
Detailed Explanation
In Kiruna, three processes are recognized concerning heritage: heritagisation (designating buildings as heritage), re-heritagisation (emphasizing the importance of buildings previously designated as heritage), and de-heritagisation (deciding certain buildings no longer hold heritage value). Understanding these processes helps clarify how the community navigates decisions about heritage during relocation.
Examples & Analogies
Imagine a college that has a building designated as a historical site. Over the years, as new structures emerge, students might decide the old building isn't fit for use anymore (de-heritagisation), but then a new group of alumni advocates to preserve it for its historical significance (re-heritagisation). This cycle reflects how communities often reevaluate what is deemed important.
Challenges and Uncertainties in Planning
Chapter 6 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So that is where they started looking at the last stage of in a more practical way of how we can deal with these certain buildings, you know so the de-heritagisation process have started.
Detailed Explanation
As the relocation progresses, decision-makers often face practical challenges at the final stage, specifically regarding which buildings can be moved or preserved. This uncertainty can complicate the planning process, as financial considerations and heritage assessments weigh against urgent time constraints and logistical needs.
Examples & Analogies
When a family decides to move, they often find themselves having to sort through their belongings. They might struggle with whether to take their old couch (heritage) or buy a new one due to the cost and space limitations in a new home (de-heritagisation). This reflects the practical challenges faced by communities during relocation.
Interdependent Relationships Among Stakeholders
Chapter 7 of 7
🔒 Unlock Audio Chapter
Sign up and enroll to access the full audio experience
Chapter Content
So there is always a tripartite relationship with these 3 stakeholders.
Detailed Explanation
In Kiruna, the relationship among the LKAB, Kiruna Kommun, and the local community exhibits interdependence, with each stakeholder relying on the others for support. This complex dynamic can often lead to confusion about responsibilities and decision-making authority in the relocation efforts.
Examples & Analogies
Consider a sports team where the players depend on coaches for strategy and the audience for support. If the players and coaches disagree on how to approach a game, the team's performance can suffer. Similarly, the interdependent relationships in Kiruna can lead to challenges if the stakeholders do not align on relocation goals.
Key Concepts
-
Heritagisation: Acknowledging the historical significance of buildings.
-
Stakeholder Engagement: The involvement of various parties in decision-making.
-
Practical Considerations: The financial and logistical issues faced during relocation.
Examples & Applications
The relocation of Kiruna's Church, a heritage structure requiring careful planning due to its intricate design.
Community consultations to understand residents' emotional attachments to their homes and help inform relocation strategies.
Memory Aids
Interactive tools to help you remember key concepts
Rhymes
In Kiruna's space, history's face, relocations we will trace, to keep our heritage in place.
Stories
Once in Kiruna, the town learned their buildings whispered stories of the past. They knew that moving them would not just change places but weave new tales, preserving their identity for generations.
Memory Tools
Think of H-R-D for Heritagisation, Re-heritagisation, and De-heritagisation to remember the processes involved.
Acronyms
K-L-C for Kiruna, LKAB, and Community, the key players in the relocation drama!
Flash Cards
Glossary
- Heritagisation
The process of recognizing and formalizing the significance of heritage sites.
- Reheritagisation
The reaffirmation and importance assigned to heritage buildings that are preserved and relocated.
- Deheritagisation
The process of dismissing or deciding against certain buildings for preservation during relocation.
- LKAB
Luossavaara-Kiirunavaara Aktiebolag, the state-owned mining company impacting Kiruna.
- Kiruna Kommun
The municipal government of Kiruna, responsible for local administration.
- Stakeholder
Individuals or groups with an interest or concern in a project or outcome.
Reference links
Supplementary resources to enhance your learning experience.